Should Race Matter?

Unusual Answers to the Usual Questions

Should Race Matter?
  • By David Boonin

  • Publisher: Cambridge University Press

    Online Publication Date:June 2012

    Online ISBN:9781139003650

    Hardback ISBN:9780521760867

    Paperback ISBN:9780521149808

  • Book DOI:

    Subjects: Ethics

In this book, philosopher David Boonin attempts to answer the moral questions raised by five important and widely contested racial practices: slave reparations, affirmative action, hate speech restrictions, hate crime laws, and racial profiling. Arguing from premises that virtually everyone on both sides of the debates over these issues already accepts, Boonin arrives at an unusual and unorthodox set of conclusions, one that is neither liberal nor conservative, color conscious nor color blind. Defended with the rigor that has characterized his previous work but written in a more widely accessible style, this provocative and important new book is sure to spark controversy and should be of interest to philosophers, legal theorists, and anyone interested in trying to resolve the debate over these important and divisive issues.


"David Boonin’s Should Race Matter? is the finest book written on the topic and should be required reading for anyone doing serious research in the field. The book contains new and powerful arguments, a comprehensive discussion of the literature, and is written in an organized and highly readable manner. It is superb. Boonin’s analyses of key issues in racial ethics are consistent, compelling, and surprising. For example, his discussion of affirmative action is a unique contribution to the literature and provides an insightful and wide-ranging discussion of the rights- and policy-based arguments both for and against this controversial program. This book, along with his previous books on abortion (A Defense of Abortion) and punishment (The Problem of Punishment), establishes Boonin as one of the most important philosophers in the world today."
Stephen Kershnar, State University of New York at Fredonia

"Boonin's treatment of this jaggedly emotional issue is meticulous, sober, and ultimately nonpartisan. There is no posturing, no demonizing - only a profoundly honest logic seldom brought to this topic, or any other."
David Schmidtz, University of Arizona

"… This is an important book that will be useful in potentially heated classroom discussions on race and public policy … Highly recommended …"
T. L. Lott, San Jose State University, Choice

"Boonin’s book is outstanding. It will reshape the discussion of these issues and is required reading for people doing research on race-policies … Like his earlier work on punishment and abortion, Boonin’s analyses are razor sharp, accessible, and interesting."
Law and Philosophy

Reference Type: notes


Reference Type: bibliography

Abramovsky, Abraham1992Bias Crime: Is Parental Liability the Answer?Annual Survey of American Law4533
ACLU2005David Erik NelsonRacial ProfilingFarmington Hills, MIGreenhaven Press
ACLU2006Kris HirschmannRacial ProfilingFarmington Hills, MI
Adams, David M.2005Punishing Hate and Achieving EqualityCriminal Justice Ethics2419
Adams, Francis D.Barry Sanders2003Alienable Rights: The Exclusion of African Americans in a White Man’s Land, 1619–2000New YorkHarperCollins Publishers, Inc
Adler, Jonathan1993Crime Rates by Race and Causal Relevance: A Reply to LevinJournal of Social Philosophy24176
Adler, Jonathan1994More on Race and Crime: Levin’s ReplyJournal of Social Philosophy25105
Alexander, Larry1996Banning Hate Speech and the Sticks and Stones DefenseConstitutional Commentary1371
Alger, Jonathan R.1998Unfinished Homework for Universities: Making the Case for Affirmative ActionJournal of Urban and Contemporary Law5473
Allen, ErnestRobert Chrisman2001Ten Reasons: A Response to David HorowitzThe Black Scholar3149
Alston, Wilton D.Walter E. Block2008Reparations, Once AgainHuman Rights Review9379
Altman, Andrew1993Liberalism and Campus Hate Speech: A Philosophical ExaminationEthics103302
Altman, Andrew2001The Democratic Legitimacy of Bias Crime Laws: Public Reason and the Political ProcessLaw and Philosophy20141
America, Richard F.1990AmericaThe Wealth of Races: The Present Value of Benefits from Past InjusticesNew YorkGreenwood Press
America, Richard F.1993Paying the Social Debt: What White America Owes Black AmericaWestport, CTPraeger
America, Richard F.1997Michael T. MartinMarilyn YaquintoRedress for Historical Injustices in the United States: On Reparations for Slavery, Jim Crow, and Their LegaciesDurham, NC, and LondonDuke University Press
Amnesty International2006Hirschmann
Appiah, K. Anthony1996Color Conscious: The Political Morality of RacePrincetonPrinceton University Press
Arceneaux, Taniecea2005Reparations for Slavery: A Cause for Reparations, a Case Against David HorowitzThe Review of Black Political Economy32141
Armour, Jody David1997Negrophobia and Reasonable Racism: The Hidden Costs of Being Black in AmericaNew York and LondonNew York University Press
Armstrong, Margalynne2002Reparations Litigation: What About Unjust Enrichment?Oregon Law Review81771
Arneson, Richard. J.1993Steven M. CahnAffirmative Action and the University: A Philosophical InquiryPhiladelpiaTemple University Press
Arnold, N. Scott1998Affirmative Action and the Demands of JusticeSocial Philosophy and Policy15133
Arthur, John2007Race, Equality, and the Burdens of HistoryCambridgeCambridge University Press
Asante, Molefi Kete2003Raymond A. WinbushShould American Pay?: Slavery and the Raging Debate on ReparationsNew YorkHarperCollins Publishers, Inc.
Ayres, Ian2008
Ayres, IanJonathan Borowsky2008
Baehr, Amy R.2003A Feminist Liberal Approach to Hate Crime LegislationJournal of Social Philosophy34134
Baez, Benjamin2002Affirmative Action, Hate Speech, and Tenure: Narratives about Race, Law and the AcademyNew York and LondonRoutledge Falmer
Bailey-Williams, Sheryl1990An Appraisal of the Estimated Rates of Slave ExploitationRichard F. AmericaThe Wealth of Races55
Baker, Houston A.2008Betrayal: How Black Intellectuals Have Abandoned the Ideals of the Civil Rights EraNew YorkColumbia University Press
Barkley, Charles2005Who’s Afraid of a Large Black Man?New YorkThe Penguin Press
Beauchamp, Tom L.1998In Defense of Affirmative ActionThe Journal of Ethics2143
Becker, Lawrence C.1993
Beckwith, Francis J.Todd E. Jones1997Affirmative Action: Social Justice or Reverse Discrimination?Amherst, New YorkPrometheus Books
Beinert, Peter2002Off-ColorThe New Republic2278
Beinert PeterBetter Safe2002National Review5417
Bilford, Brian J.2008Harper’s Bazaar: The Marketplace of Ideas and Hate Speech in SchoolsStanford Journal of Civil Rights and Civil Liberties4101
Bittker, Boris I.1973The Case for Black ReparationsNew YorkRandom House
Black, Virginia1974The Erosion of Legal Principles in the Creation of Legal Policies,Ethics8493
Blackmon, Douglas A.2008Slavery by Another Name: The Re-Enslavement of Black Americans from the Civil War to World War IINew YorkDoubleday
Blair, John P.Rudy H. Fichtenbaum1992George C. GalsterEdward W. HillThe Metropolis in Black & White: Place, Power and PolarizationNew Brunswick, NJCenter for Urban Policy Research
Blake, Michael2001Geeks and Monsters: Bias Crimes and Social IdentityLaw and Philosophy20121
Blum, Lawrence2002“I’m Not a Racist, But …”: The Moral Quandary of RaceIthaca, NY, and LondonCornell University Press
Blumstein, Alfred1982Shaun L. GabbidonHelen Taylor GreeneRace, Crime, and JusticeNew YorkRoutledge2005
Block, Walter2002On Reparations to Blacks for SlaveryHuman Rights Review353
Bolick, Clint1996The Affirmative Action Fraud: Can We Restore the American Civil Rights Vision?Washington, DCthe Cato Institute
Bolner, James1968
Boonin, David2008The Problem of PunishmentCambridgeCambridge University Press
Boonin, David2008How to Solve the Non-Identity ProblemPublic Affairs Quarterly22127
Bowen, William G.Derek Bok1998The Shape of the River: Long-Term Consequences of Considering Race in College and University AdmissionsPrincetonPrinceton University Press
Boxill, Bernard R.1992Blacks and Social JusticeLanham, MDRowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.
Boyle, Kevin2001Hate Speech – The United States Versus the Rest of the World?Maine Law Review53488
Brick, Michael2007Lawyer Claims Defendant in Hate Crime Is Gay, TooNew York Times
Brick, Michael2003Brief of the Harvard Black Law Students Association, Stanford Black Law Students Association and Yale Black Law Students Association as Supporting RespondentsHarvard BlackLetter Law Journal1955
Brooks, Roy L.2003John TorpeyPolitics and the Past: On Repairing Historical InjusticesLanham, MDRowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.
Brooks, Roy L.2004Atonement and Forgiveness: A New Model for Black ReparationsBerkeleyUniversity of California Press
Brophy, Alfred L.2003Some Conceptual and Legal Problems in Reparations for SlaveryNYU Annual Survey of American Law58497
Brophy, Alfred L.2004The Cultural War Over Reparations For SlaveryDePaul Law Review531181
Brophy, Alfred L.2006Reconsidering ReparationsIndiana Law Journal81811
Brown, Ralph S.1992Susan Gellman Has it RightCriminal Justice Ethics1146
Browne, Robert S.1990Richard F. America
Browne, Robert S.1993MartinYaquinto
Browne-Marshall, Gloria2007Race, Law and American Society: 1607 to PresentNew YorkRoutledge
Brownstein, Alan E.1994Hate Speech and Harassment: The Constitutionality of Campus Codes that Prohibit Racial InsultsWilliam and Mary Bill of Rights Journal3179
BuckleyWilliam F.2002Watch the Red-Haired ManNational Review5462
Buckman, William H.John Lamberth2001Challenging Racial Profiles: Attacking Jim Crow on the InterstateRutgers Race and the Law Review383
Butler, Paul1997Affirmative Action and the Criminal LawUniversity of Colorado Law Review68841
Canedy, Dana2001The New York Times, How Race is Lived in America: Pulling Together, Pulling ApartNew YorkHenry Holt and Company
Cantor, Nancy2004Defending Diversity: Affirmative Action at the University of MichiganAnn ArborUniversity of Michigan Press
Capaldi, Nicholas1996Affirmative Action: Social Justice or Unfair Preference?Lanham, MDRowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.
Card, Claudia2001Is Penalty Enhancement a Sound Idea?Law and Philosophy20195
Card, Robert F.2005Making Sense of the Diversity-Based Legal Argument for Affirmative ActionPublic Affairs Quarterly1911
Carter, Stephen L.1991Reflections of an Affirmative Action BabyNew YorkBasic Books
CarterWilliam M.2004A Thirteenth Amendment Framework for Combating Racial ProfilingHarvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review3917
Chemerinsky, Erwin1996Making Sense of the Affirmative Action DebateOhio Northern University Law Review221343
Cho, Sumi K.1997Multiple Consciousness and the Diversity DilemmaUniversity of Colorado Law Review681035
Cohen, Carl1995Naked Racial PreferenceNew YorkMadison Books
Cohen, Carl1998Preference by Race in University Admissions and the Quest for DiversityJournal of Urban and Contemporary Law5443
Cohen, Carl2003Carl CohenJames P. SterbaAffirmative Action and Racial Preference: A DebateOxfordOxford University Press
Cohen, Carl2003
Colb, Sherry F.2001Stopping a Moving TargetRutgers Race and the Law Review3191
Collier, Charles W.2005Affirmative Action and the Decline of Intellectual CultureJournal of Legal Education553
Connerly, Ward1996BeckwithJones
Conti, Joseph G.Brad Stetson1997Stan FarynaBrad StetsonJoseph G. ContiBlack and Right: The Bold New Voice of Black Conservatives in AmericaWestport, CTPraeger
Cooper, Steve2006Steven J. MufflerRacial Profiling: Issues, Data and AnalysesNew YorkNova Science Publishers, Inc.
Corlett, J. Angelo2003Race, Racism and ReparationsIthaca, NY, and LondonCornell University Press
Corry, Robert J.1996Affirmative Action: An Innocent Generation’s Equality SacrificedOhio Northern University Law Review221177
Corry, Robert J.1996Quotas, Special Privileges and Affirmative ActionOhio Northern University Law Review221305
Cortese, Anthony2006Opposing Hate SpeechWestport, CTPraeger
Cox, Chana Berniker1993On Michael Levin’s ‘Responses to Race Differences in Crime’Journal of Social Philosophy24155
Cox, Philip N.1995The Disputation of Hate: Speech Codes, Pluralism, and Academic FreedomsSocial Theory and Practice21113
Crawford, JewelWade W. NoblesJoy DeGruy Leary2003Winbush
Crocker, Lawrence1992Hate Crime Statutes: Just? Constitutional? Wise?Annual Survey of American Law485
Dagan, Hanoch2004Restitution and Slavery: On Incomplete Commodification, Intergenerational Justice, and Legal TransitionsBoston University Law Review841139
Danziger, SheldonPeter Gottschalk1990Richard F. America
DarrityWilliamDania Frank2003MartinYaquinto
Davies, Sharon2003Profiling TerrorOhio State Journal of Criminal Law146
Davis, Adrienne D.2000MartinYaquinto
Davis, Angelique M.2007Multiracialism and Reparations The Intersection of the Multiracial Category and the Reparations MovementsThomas Jefferson Law Review29161
Delgado, Richard1993Words That Wound: Critical Race Theory, Assaultive Speech, and the First AmendmentBoulder, COWestview Press
Delgado, Richard1995Laura J. LedererRichard DelgadoThe Price We Pay: The Case Against Racist Speech, Hate Propoganda, and PornographyNew YorkHill and Wang
Delgado, Richard1997Why Universities Are Morally Obligated to Strive for Diversity: Restoring the Remedial Rationale for Affirmative ActionUniversity of Colorado Law Review681165
Delgado, Richard2006
Derbyshire, John2001In Defense of Racial Profiling,National Review5338
Derbyshire, John2001At First GlanceNational Review5342
Desai, Anuj C.2003Attacking with History: Does the Long-Term Harm of Biased Speech Justify a Criminal Statute Suppressing It?Federal Communications Law Journal55353
Dieterle, J. M.2005Affirmative Action and DesertPublic Affairs Quarterly1981
Dillon, Sam2009Study Sees an Obama Effect As Lifting Black Test-TakersNew York TimesA15
Douard, John2001Racial Profiling: A New Road HazardRutgers Race and the Law Review31
D’Souza, Dinesh1995The End of RacismNew YorkThe Free Press
D’Souza, Dinesh1999Sometimes Discrimination Can Make SenseUSA Today15A
Durlauf, Steven N.2008Affirmative Action, Meritocracy, and EfficiencyPolitics, Philosophy and Economics7131
Dworkin, Ronald2003The Court and the UniversityUniversity of Cincinnati Law Review72883
Eastland, Terry1997Ending Affirmative Action: The Case for Colorblind JusticeNew YorkBasic Books
Egan, Timothy2001
Ehlmann, Steven E.1998Another Approach to Racial PreferencesJournal of Urban and Contemporary Law5493
Ehrlich, Howard J.Barbara E. K. LarcomRobert D. Purvis1995LedererDelgado
Ellman, Stephen J.2003Racial Profiling and TerrorismNew York Law School Law Review46675
Engerman, Stanley L.1990Richard F. America
Epstein, Richard A.2004The Case Black ReparationsBoston University Law Review841177
Ezorsky, Gertrude1991Racism and Justice: The Case For Affirmative ActionIthaca and LondonCornell University Press
Farrior, Stephanie1996Molding The Matrix: The Historical and Theoretical Foundations of International Law Concerning Hate SpeechBerkeley Journal of International Law141
Fauchon, Christina2004Counterpoint: The Case Against ProfilingInternational Social Science Review79157
Fauchon, Christina2006Hirschmann
Feagin, Joe R.2000Racist America: Roots, Current Realities, and Future ReparationsNew York and LondonRoutledge
Feiner, Susan F.Bruce B. Roberts1990Richard F. America
Finkelman, Paul1999Affirmative Action for the Master Class: The Creation of the Proslavery ConstitutionAkron Law Review32423
Fish, Stanley1993
Fiss, Owen1995The Supreme Court and the Problem of Hate SpeechCapital University Law Review24281
Forman, James1969
FormanJames2001Arrested DevelopmentThe New Republic22524
Fortson, Ryan2004Correcting the Harms of Slavery: Collective Liability, the Limited Prospects of Success for a Class Action Suit for Slavery Reparations, and the Reconceptualization of White Racial IdentityAfrican-American Law & Policy ReportVI71
Frady, Marshall2002Luther KingNew YorkViking Penguin
Francis, Leslie Pickering1993Cahn
Freeman, Steven M.1992Hate Crime Laws: Punishment Which Fits the CrimeAnnual Survey of American Law581
Frum, David2003Support Your PoliceNational Review5560
Fullinwider, Robert2000The Case for ReparationsPhilosophy and Public Policy Quarterly20
Fullinwider, Robert2004The Reparations Argument: A ReplyJournal of Social Philosophy35256
Fullinwider, Robert K.Judith Lichtenberg2004Leveling the Playing Field: Justice, Politics and College AdmissionsLatham, MDRowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.
Fund, John H.2006Profiling EncouragedThe American Spectator3952
Galster, George C.Edward W. Hill1992GalsterHill
Gates, Henry Louis1997Thirteen Ways of Looking at a Black ManNew YorkRandom House
Gellman, Susan1991Sticks and Stones Can Put You in Jail, but Can Words Increase Your Sentence?: Constitutional and Policy Dilemmas of Ethnic Intimidation LawsUCLA Law Review39333
Gellman, Susan1992‘Brother, You Can’t Go to Jail for What You’re Thinking’: Motives, Effects, and ‘Hate Crime’ LawsCriminal Justice Ethics1124
Gellman, Susan1992Hate Crime Laws Are Thought Crime LawsAnnual Survey of American Law509
Gellman, Susan1995Hate Speech and a New View of the First AmendmentCapital University Law Review24309
Gellman, Susan1995Hate Crime Laws After Ohio Northern University Law Review21863
Gellman, Susan2005The Case Against Bias-Crimes Laws.” In Susan B. Gellman and Frederick M. Lawrence, “Agreeing to Agree: A Proponent and Opponent of Hate Crime Laws Reach for Common GroundHarvard Journal on Legislation41425
Gerstenfeld, Phyllis B.2004Hate Crimes: Causes, Controls, and ControversiesThousand Oaks, CASage Publications.
Glasser, Ira2000
Graglia, Lino A.1998The ‘Affirmative Action’ FraudJournal of Urban and Contemporary Law5431
Gray, Danielle C.Travis LeBlanc2003Integrating Elite Law Schools and the Legal Profession: A View from the Black Law Students Associations of Harvard, Standord, and Yale Law SchoolsHarvard BlackLetter Law Journal1943
Gross, Barry R.1978Discrimination in Reverse: Is Turnabout Fair Play?New YorkNew York University Press
Gross, Samuel R.Katherine Y., Barnes2002Road Work: Racial Profiling and Drug Interdiction on the HighwayMichigan Law Review101653
Golab, Jan1999Probable CauseLos Angeles Magazine,4428.
Goldberger, David1992Hate Crime Laws and Their Impact on the First AmendmentAnnual Survey of American Law569
Goldman, Alan H.1979Justice and Reverse DiscriminationPrincetonPrinceton University Press
Goldman, Alan H.1993Cahn
Gould, Jon B.2005Speak No Evil: The Triumph of Hate Speech RegulationChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press
Graves, Joseph L.2005The Race Myth: Why We Pretend Race Exists in AmericaNew YorkPenguin Books
Greenawalt, Kent.1992Reflections on Justifications for Defining Crimes by the Category of VictimAnnual Survey of American Law617
Greve, Michael S.1992Hate Crimes and HypocrisyAnnual Survey of American Law563
Groarke, Leo1990Affirmative Action as a Form of RestitutionJournal of Business Ethics9207
Gumbhir, Vikas K.2007But Is It Profiling?: Policing, Pretext Stops, and the Color of SuspicionNew YorkLFB Scholarly Publishing LLC
Gurin, PatriciaEric L. DeyGerald GurinSylvia Hurtado2004
Gutmann, Amy1996
Hacker, Andrew2003Two Nations: Black & White, Separate, Hostile, UnequalNew YorkSimon & Schuster
Hackney, James R.2004Ideological Conflict, African American Reparations, Tort Causation and the Case for Social Welfare TransformationBoston University Law Review841193
Hajdin, Mane2002Affirmative Action, Old and NewJournal of Social Philosophy3383
Hanson, Karen1993Cahn
Harrell, AlonGideon Parchomovsky1999On Hate and EqualityYale Law Journal109507
Harris, David A.2001Law Enforcement’s Stake in Coming to Grips with Racial ProfilingRutgers Race and the Law Review39
Harris, David A.2002Profiles in Injustice: Why Racial Profiling Cannot WorkNew YorkThe New Press
Harris, Luke CharlesUma Naryan2007Ethics in Practice: An AnthologyMalden, MABlackwell Publishing
Hartle, Ann1993Cahn
Harmon, Amy2001
Harvey, Jennifer2007Whiteness and Morality: Pursuing Racial Justice through Reparations and SovereigntyNew YorkPalgrave Macmillan
Heriot, Gail2008Affirmative Action in American Law SchoolsThe Journal of Contemporary Legal Issues17237
Hernandez, GarciaCesar Cuauhtemoc2009La Migra in the Mirror: Immigration Enforcement and Racial Profiling on the Texas BorderNotre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics and Public Policy23167
Herrnstein, Richard J.Charles Murray1994The Bell Curve: Intelligence and Class Structure in American LifeNew YorkFree Press
Herstein, Ori2008
Herstein, Ori2008Historic Injustice and the Non-Identity Problem; The Limitations of the Subsequent-Wrong Solution and Towards a New SolutionLaw and Philosophy27505
Heumann, MiltonLance Cassak2003Good Cop, Bad Cop: Racial Profiling and Competing Views of JusticeNew YorkPeter Lang
Hill, Thomas1991The Message of Affirmative ActionSocial Philosophy and Policy8108
Himma, Kenneth Einar2002It’s the Rationale that Counts: A Reply to NewtonJournal of Business Ethics37407
Hitchens, Christopher2003Winbush
Holbert, SteveLisa Rose2006Nelson
Holmes, Steven A.2001
Horowitz, David2002Uncivil Wars: The Controversy Over Reparations For SlaverySan FranciscoEncounter Books
Hughes, Graham1968Reparations for Blacks?New York University Law Review431063
Hughs, Paul M.2004Rectification and Reparation: What Does Citizen Responsibility Require?Journal of Social Philosophy35244
Hurd, Heidi M.2001Why Liberals Should Hate ‘Hate Crime Legislation’Law and Philosophy20215
Issacharoff, Samuel1998Can Affirmative Action Be Defended?Ohio State Law Journal59669
Jacobs, James B.1992Rethinking the War Against Hate Crimes: A New York City PerspectiveCriminal Justice Ethics1155
Jacobs, James B.Kimberly Potter1998Hate Crimes: Criminal Law and Identity PoliticsOxfordOxford University Press
Kahan, Dan M.2001Two Liberal Fallacies in the Hate Crimes DebateLaw and Philosophy20175
Kang, JerryMahzarin R. Banaji2006Fair Measures: A Behavioral Realist Revision of ‘Affirmative Action.’California Law Review,941063
Karabel, Jerome2005The Chosen: The Hidden History of Admission and Exclusion at Harvard, Yale and PrincetonNew YorkHoughton Mifflin
Karlan, Pamela S.2008
Kekes, John1993Cahn
Kellough, J. Edward2006Understanding Affirmative Action: Politics, Discrimination, and the Search for JusticeWashington, DCGeorgetown University Press
Kelly, Robin D. G.2003MartinYaquinto
Kennedy, Randall2002Nigger: The Strange Career of a Troublesome WordNew YorkPantheon Books
Kennedy, Randall2002Blind SpotAtlantic Monthly28924
Kennedy, Randall2008Sellout: The Politics of Racial BetrayalNew YorkPantheon Books
Kershnar, Stephen1999Strong Affirmative Action Programs and Disproportionate BurdensThe Journal of Value Inquiry33201
Kershnar, Stephen2004Justice for the PastAlbanyState University of New York Press
Kershnar, Stephen2004Ronald P. SalzbergerMary C. TurckReparations for Slavery: A ReaderLanham, MDRowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.
Kershnar, Stephen2007Race As a Factor in University AdmissionsLaw and Philosophy26437
Kidder, William C.2001Affirmative Action in Higher Education: Recent Developments in Litigation, Admissions and Diversity ResearchBerkeley La Raza Law Journal12173
Kim, Janine Young2006Hate Crime Law and the Limits of InculpationNebraska Law Review84846
Kinder, Donald R.Lynn M. Sanders1996Divided by Color: Racial Politics and Democratic IdealsChicago and LondonUniversity of Chicago Press
Klarman, Michael J.2007Unfinished Business: Racial Equality in American HistoryOxfordOxford University Press
Klimchuk, Dennis2004Unjust Enrichment and Reparations for SlaveryBoston University Law Review841257
Knechtle, John C.2005When to Regulate Hate SpeechPenn State Law Review110539
Kohn, Marek1995The Race Gallery: The Return of Racial ScienceLondonJonathan Cape, Random House
Krauthammer, Charles2002The Case for ProfilingTime159104
Krislov, Marvin2003Affirmative Action in Higher Education: the Value, the Method, and the FutureUniversity of Cincinnati Law Review72899
Kukathas, Chandran2006Who? Whom? Reparations and the Problem of AgencyJournal of Social Philosophy37330
Kupperman, Joel J.1993Cahn
Laney, Garrine P.Muffler
Lasson, Kenneth1985In Defense of Group-Libel Laws, or Why the First Amendment Should Not Protect NazisHuman Rights Annual2289
Lasson, Kenneth1986Racial Defamation as Free Speech: Abusing the First AmendmentColumbia Human Rights Law Review1711
Lasson, Kenneth1991To Stimulate, Provoke, or Incite?: Hate Speech and the First AmendmentSt. Thomas Law Forum349
Lawrence IIICharles R.1993MatsudaWords That Wound: Critical Race Theory, Assaultive Speech, and the First AmendmentBoulder, COWestview Press
Lawrence IIICharles R.Mari J. MatsudaRichard DelgadoKimberle Williams Crenshaw1993MatsudaWords That Wound: Critical Race Theory, Assaultive Speech, and the First AmendmentBoulder, COWestview Press
Lawrence, Frederick M.1993Resolving the Hate Crimes/Hate Speech Paradox: Punishing Bias Crimes and Protecting Racist SpeechNotre Dame Law Review68673
Lawrence, Frederick M.1999Punishing Hate: Bias Crimes under American LawCambridge, MAHarvard University Press
Lawrence, Frederick M.2005The Case for Bias-Crimes Laws.” In Susan B. Gellman and Frederick M. Lawrence, “Agreeing to Agree: A Proponent and Opponent of Hate Crime Laws Reach for Common GroundHarvard Journal on Legislation41422
Laycock, Douglas2004The Broader Case for Affirmative Action: Desegregation, Academic Excellence, and Future LeadershipTulane Law Review781767
Leadership Conference on Civil Rights Education Fund2006Hirschmann
LeFevre, Joseph2003The Value of Diversity: A Justification of Affirmative ActionJournal of Social Philosophy34125
Leidholdt, Dorchen1995LedererDelgado
Lever, Annabelle2005Why Racial Profiling Is Hard to Justify: A Response to Risse and ZeckhauserPhilosophy and Public Affairs3394
Lever, Annabelle2007What’s Wrong with Racial Profiling? Another Look at the ProblemCriminal Justice Ethics2620
Levey, Curt A.2003Racial Preferences in Admissions: Myths, Harms, and AlternativesAlbany Law Review66489
Levin, Michael1993Responses to Race Differences in CrimeJournal of Social Philosophy235
Levin, Michael1994Reply to Adler, Cox, and CorlettJournal of Social Philosophy255
Levin, Michael1994Reply to Adler’s ‘More on Race and Crime: Levin’s Reply’Journal of Social Philosophy25115
Levin, Michael1997Why Race Matters: Race Differences and What They MeanWestport, CTPraeger
Levmore, Saul2004Privatizing ReparationsBoston University Law Review841291
Lewin, Tamar
Liptak, Adam2008Outside U.S., Hate Speech Can Be CostlyNew York TimesA1
Logue, Kyle D.2004Reparations as RedistributionBoston University Law Review841319
London, Herbert2003Profiling as NeededAlbany Law Review66343
Loury, Glen C.2002The Anatomy of Racial InequalityCambridge, MAHarvard University Press
Loury, Glen C.Pamela S. KarlanTommie ShelbyLoic Wacquant2008Race, Incarceration, and American ValuesCambridge, MAMIT Press
Lowry, Richard2002Profiles in Cowardice,National Review5432
Lund, Nelson2003The Conservative Case Against Racial Profiling in the War on TerrorismAlbany Law Review66329
Lyons, David2004Corrective Justice, Equal Opportunity, and the Legacy of Slavery and Jim CrowBoston University Law Review841375
Lyons, David2007MartinYaquinto
Ma, Alice K.1995Campus Hate Speech Codes: Affirmative Action in the Allocation of Speech RightsCalifornia Law Review83693
Mac Donald, Heather2003Are Cops Racist?ChicagoIvan R. Dee
MacKinnon, Catharine A.1993Only WordsCambridge, MAHarvard University Press
Maclin, Tracey2001The Fourth Amendment on the FreewayRutgers Race and the Law Review3117
Mahoney, Kathleen E.1995LedererDelgado
Mahoney, Kathleen E.1996
Malamud, Deborah C.1997Affirmative Action, Diversity, and the Black Middle ClassUniversity of Colorado Law Review68939
Malik, Kenan2008Strange Fruit: Why Both Sides are Wrong in the Race DebateOxfordOneworld Publications
Marcus, Kenneth L.2008Higher Education, Harassment, and First Amendment OpportunismWilliam and Mary Bill of Rights Journal161025
Margulies, Martin B.1992Intent, Motive, and the . DecisionCriminal Justice Ethics1142
Marketti, James.1990Richard F. America
Markie, Peter J.1993Cahn
Masters, Stanley H.1990Richard F. America
Matsuda, Mari J.1993MatsudaWords That Wound: Critical Race Theory, Assaultive Speech, and the First AmendmentBoulder, COWestview Press
McCarthy, Andrew C.2006Hirschmann
McGary, Howard1977Race and Social JusticeMalden, MABlackwell Publishers
McGary, Howard1984
McGary, Howard1996
McGee, Robert W.1998Does Adoption of an Affirmative Action Policy Constitute an Act Discreditable to the Profession?: A Philosophical Look at a Practical Ethical QuestionJournal of Accounting, Ethics & Public Policy1275
McMillian, Theodore1998In Defense of Affirmative ActionJournal of Urban and Contemporary Law5439
McShane, LarryTrevor Tompson2007Survey: Young whites happier than minoritiesThe Denver Post2A
McWhirter, Darien A.1996The End of Affirmative Action: Where Do We Go From Here?New YorkBirch Lane Press
McWhorter, John2001Losing the Race: Self-Sabotage in Black AmericaNew YorkHarperCollins.
McWhorter, John2005Winning the Race: Beyond the Crisis in Black AmericaNew YorkGotham Books
Meeks, Kenneth2000Driving While Black – Highways, Shopping Malls, Taxicabs, Sidewalks: How to Fight Back If You are a Victim of Racial ProfilingNew YorkBroadway Books
Mellott, Jared M.2006The Diversity Rationale for Affirmative Action in Employment After : The Case for ContainmentWilliam & Mary Law Review1091
Michelman, Frank I.1995LedererDelgado
Moore, Jamillah2005Race and College Admissions: A Case for Affirmative ActionJefferson, NC, and LondonMcFarland & Co.
Moskos, Peter2006Driving While BlackNew York Times13
Mosley, Albert G.1996
Mosley, Albert G.1998Policies of Straw or Policies of Inclusion?: A Review of Pojman’s ‘Case against Affirmative ActionInternational Journal of Applied Philosophy12161
Muller, Eric L.2003Inference or Impact? Racial Profiling and the Internment’s True LegacyOhio State Journal of Criminal Law1104
Murphy, Jeffrie G.1992Bias Crimes: What do Haters Deserve?Criminal Justice Ethics1120
Murphy, Tanya Y.1995An Argument for Diversity Based Affirmative Action in Higher Eduction1995 Annual Survey of American Law515
Nagel, Thomas1973Marshall CohenThomas NagelThomas ScanlonEquality and Preferential TreatmentPrincetonPrinceton University Press
Nagel, Thomas1977Cohen
Navarro, Mireya2001
Neal, Larry1990Richard F. America
Nearpass, Gregory R.2002The Overlooked Constitutional Objection and Practical Concerns To Penalty-Enhancement Provisions of Hate Crime LegislationAlbany Law Review66547
Newton, Lisa1973Reverse Discrimination as UnjustifiedEthics83308
Nzingha, Yaa Asantewa2003Winbush
Ogletree, Charles J.2003The Current Reparations DebateU.C. Davis Law Review361051
Ogletree, Charles J.2003Repairing the Past: New Efforts in the Reparations Debate in AmericaHarvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review38279
Ogletree, Charles J.2003Reparations for the Children of Slaves: Litigating the IssuesThe University of Memphis Law Review33245
Ogletree, Charles J.2004Tulsa Reparations: The Survivors’ StoryBoston College Third World Law Journal2413
Olafson, Frederick A.1993Cahn
Oliver, Melvin L.Thomas M. Shapiro2006Black Wealth/White Wealth: A New Perspective on Racial InequalityNew YorkRoutledge
Osei, Akwasi1992GalsterHill
Outterson, Kevin2003Winbush
Outterson, Kevin2009The End of Reparations Talk: Reparations in an Obama WorldKansas Law Review57101
Paterson, Eva Jefferson2004And Still We RiseAfrican-American Law & Policy Report615
Paul, Ellen Frankel1993Cahn
Pampel, Fred C.2004Racial ProfilingNew YorkFacts on File
Pell, Terence J.2003Racial Preferences and Formal EqualityJournal of Social Philosophy34309
Pettigrove, Glen2003Apology, Reparations, and The Question of Inherited GuiltPublic Affairs Quarterly17319
Pojman, Louis P.1992BeckwithJones
Pojman, Louis P.1993Race and Crime: A Response to Michael Levin and Laurence ThomasJournal of Social Philosophy24152
Pojman, Louis P.1998The Case Against Affirmative ActionInternational Journal of Applied Philosophy1297
Pojman, Louis P.1998Straw Man or Straw Theory?: A Reply to Albert MosleyInternational Journal of Applied Philosophy12169
Pollak, Joseph D.2009
Purdy, Laura1984In Defense of Hiring Apparently Less Qualified WomenJournal of Social Philosophy152, pp
Purdy, Laura1994Why Do We Need Affirmative Action?Journal of Social Philosophy25133
Quinn, Philip L.1993Cahn
Rachels, James1993Cahn
Ramirez, DeborahJack McDevittAmy Farrell2006Muffler
Ransom, Roger L.Richard Sutch1990Richard F. America
Raphael, Alan2005Affirmative Action and Admissions at a Jesuit Law SchoolLoyola University Chicago Law Journal36579
Reddick Sharon R.2004Point: The Case for ProfilingInternational Social Science Review79154
Redish, Martin H.1992Freedom of Thought as Freedom of Expression: Hate Crime Sentencing Enhancement and First Amendment TheoryCriminal Justice Ethics1129
Reed, Fred2006Hirschmann
Reidy, David A.2004Christine T. SistareCivility and Its Discontents: Essays on Civic Virtue, Toleration, and Cultural FragmentationLawrenceUniversity of Kansas Press
Richburg, Keith B.1997Out of America: A Black Man Confronts AfricaNew YorkBasic Books
Riggs, Robert R.1995Punishing the Politically Incorrect Offender Through ‘Bias Motive’ Enhancements: Compelling Necessity or First Amendment Folly?Ohio Northern University Law Review21945
Risse, Mathias.2007Racial Profiling: A Reply to Two CriticsCriminal Justice Ethics264
Risse, MathiasRichard Zeckhauser2004Racial ProfilingPhilosophy and Public Affairs32131
Robinson, Paul. H.1992Hate Crimes: Crimes of Motive, Character, or Group Terror?Annual Survey of American Law605
Robinson, Randall2000The Debt: What America Owes to BlacksNew YorkPenguin Putnam
Robinson, Randall2000MartinYaquinto
Robinson, Randall2000David BooninGraham OddieWhat’s Wrong?, Second EditionOxfordOxford University Press
Robinson, Randall2004What America Owes to Blacks and What Blacks Owe to Each OtherAfrican-American Law & Policy Report61
Romero, Victor C.2003Critical Race Theory in Three Acts: Racial Profiling, Affirmative Action, and the Diversity Visa LotteryAlbany Law Review66375
Rubinstein, Mitchell H.1985The Affirmative Action ControversyHofstra Labor and Employment Law Journal3111
Sabbagh, Daniel2007Equality and Transparency: A Strategic Perspective on Affirmative Action in American LawNew YorkPalgrave Macmillan
Sack, Kevin2001
Sack, KevinJanet Elder2001
Sadurski, Wojciech1999Freedom of Speech and Its LimitsDordrechtKluwer Academic Publishers
Sarich, VincentFrank Miele2005Race: The Reality of Human DifferencesBoulder, COWestview Press
Schauer, Frederick2003Profiles, Probabilities and StereotypesCambridge, MAHarvard University Press
Schedler, George1998Racist Symbols and Reparations: Philosophical Reflections on Vestiges of the American Civil WarLanham, MDRowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.
Schedler, George2002Principles for Measuring the Damages of American SlaveryPublic Affairs Quarterly16377
Sebok, Anthony J.2004Two Concepts of Injustice in Restitution for SlaveryBoston University Law Review841405
Secours, Molly2003Winbush
Sepinwall, Amy J.2006Responsibility for Historical Injustices: Reconceiving the Case for ReparationsJournal of Law & PoliticsXXII183
Sharp, Andrew1997Justice and the Maori: The Philosophy and Practice of Maori Claims in New Zealand since the 1970s, Second EditionAuckland, NZOxford University Press
Shelton, La Verne1993Cahn
Sher, George1999DiversityPhilosophy and Public Affairs2885
Sherwin, Emily2004Reparations and Unjust EnrichmentBoston University Law Review841443
Shiell, Timothy C.1998Campus Hate Speech on TrialLawrenceUniversity Press of Kansas
Shiffrin, Seana Valentine2009Melinda A. RobertsDavid T. WassermanHarming Future Persons: Ethics, Genetics and the Nonidentity ProblemLondonSpringer
Simon, Robert1974Preferential Hiring: A Reply to Judith Jarvis ThomsonPhilosophy and Public Affairs3312
Simon, Robert L.1993Cahn
Simmons, A. John1995Historical Rights and Fair SharesLaw and Philosophy14149
Sistare, Christine2004Sistare
Smith, Errol1997Faryna, StetsonConti
Somin, Ilya2006Nelson
Sommers, Fred1993Cahn
Sowell, Thomas2004Affirmative Action Around the World: An Empirical StudyNew Haven, CT, LondonYale University Press
Stark, Susan2004Taking Responsibility for Oppression: Affirmative Action and Racial InjusticePublic Affairs Quarterly18205
Steele, Shelby1990Content of Our Character: A New Vision of Race in AmericaNew YorkSt. Martin’s Press
Steele, Shelby1998A Dream Deferred: The Second Betrayal of Black Freedom in AmericaNew YorkHarperCollins Publishers
Steele, Shelby2006White Guilt: How Blacks and Whites Together Destroyed the Promise of the Civil Rights EraNew YorkHarperCollins Publishers
Steele, Shelby2008A Bound Man: Why We Are Excited About Obama and Why He Can’t WinNew YorkFree Press
Sterba, James P.1993Cahn
Sterba, James P.2003Defending Affirmative Action, Defending PreferencesJournal of Social Philosophy34285
Sterba, James P.2003
Strike, Kenneth A.2006
Strossen, Nadine1996Hate Speech and Pornography: Do We Have to Choose Between Freedom of Speech and Equality?Case Western Reserve Law Review46449
Strossen, Nadine2001Incitement to Hatred: Should There Be a Limit?Southern Illinois University Law Journal25243
Subotnik, Dan2005Toxic Diversity: Race, Gender, and Law Talk in AmericaNew YorkNew York University Press
Sunstein, Cass1993Democracy and the Problem of Free SpeechNew YorkFree Press
Tabb, William M.2005Reflections on DiversityJournal of Legal Education5528
Taslitz, Andrew E.1999Condemning the Racist Personality: Why the Critics of Hate Crimes Legislation Are WrongBoston College Law Review40739
Thernstrom, StephanAbigail Thernstrom1997America in Black and White: One Nation, IndivisibleNew YorkSimon & Schuster
Thomas, George C. III.2001Blinded by the Light: How to Deter Racial Profiling – Thinking About RemediesRutgers Race and the Law Review339
Thomas, Laurence1992Statistical BadnessJournal of Social Philosophy2330
Thomas, Laurence1993Cahn
Thomas, Laurence2003Equality and the Mantra of DiversityUniversity of Cincinnati Law Review72931
Thompson, Ginger2001
Thomson, Judith Jarvis1973Preferential HiringPhilosophy and Public Affairs2364
Tsesis, Aleander2000The Empirical Shortcomings of First Amendment Jurisprudence; a Historical Perspective on the Power of Hate SpeechSanta Clara Law Review40729
Tsesis, Aleander2002Destructive Messages: How Hate Speech Paves the Way for Harmful Social MovementsNew YorkNew York University Press
Turnbull, Robert G.1993Cahn
Tutu, Nontombi2003Winbush
United States Department of Justice2003
United States General Accounting Office2006Muffler
Valls, Andrew1999The Libertarian Case for Affirmative ActionSocial Theory and Practice25299
Van Dyke, Jon M.2003Winbush
Vedder, RichardLowell GallawayDavid C. Klingaman1990Richard F. America
Waldron, Jeremy1992Superseding Historic InjusticeEthics1034
Waldstreicher, David2009Slavery’s Constitution: From Revolution to RatificationNew YorkHill and Wang
Walker, Samuel1994Hate Speech: The History of an American ControversyLincolnUniversity of Nebraska Press
Wang, Lu-in1997The Transforming Power of ‘Hate’: Social Cognition Theory and the Harms of Bias-Related CrimeSouthern California Law Review7147
Wang, Lu-in1999The Complexities of ‘Hate’Ohio State Law Journal60799
Wang, Lu-in2000Recognizing Opportunistic Bias CrimesBoston University Law Review801399
Wang, Lu-in2001’Suitable Targets’?: Parallels and Connections Between ‘Hate’Crimes and ‘Driving While Black’Michigan Journal of Race and Law6209
Wang, Lu-in2002Hate Crime and Everyday Discrimination: Influences of and on the Social ContextRutgers Race and the Law Review41
Wang, Lu-in2002Unwarranted Assumptions in the Prosecution and Defense of Hate CrimesCriminal Justice175
Weinstein, James1992First Amendment Challenges to Hate Crime Legislation: Where’s the Speech?Criminal Justice Ethics116
Weinstein, James1992Some Further Thoughts on ‘Thought Crimes’Criminal Justice Ethics1161
Weinstein, James1999Hate Speech, Pornography, and the Radical Attack on Free Speech DoctrineBoulder, COWestview Press
Wellman, Christopher Heath2006A Defense of Stiffer Penalties for Hate CrimesHypatia2162
Wenger, Kaimipono David2006Causation and Attenuation in the Slavery Reparations DebateUniversity of San Francisco Law Review279
Westley, Robert2003Winbush
Westmoreland, Robert2003A New and Improved Affirmative Action?University of Cincinnati Law Review72909
White, David M.2001The Requirement of Race-Conscious Evaluation of LSAT Scores for Equitable Law School AdmissionsBerkeley La Raza Law Journal12399
Wicker, Tom1996Tragic Failure: Racial Integration in AmericaNew YorkWillam Morrow and Company, Inc
Will, George F.2007
Williams, Armstrong2003Winbush
Williams, David RChiquita Collins2004MartinYaquinto
Williams, Juan2006Enough: The Phony Leaders, Dead-End Movements, and Culture of Failure That Are Undermining Black America – and What We Can Do About ItNew YorkCrown Publishers
Winerip, Michael2001
Winbush, Raymond A.2003Winbush
Winbush, Raymond A.2003Winbush
Wise, Tim2008White Like Me: Reflections on Race from a Privileged SonBrooklyn, NYSoft Skull Press
Withrow, Brian L.2006Racial Profiling: From Rhetoric to ReasonUpper Saddle River, NJPearson Prentice Hall
Woods, Jordan Blair2008Taking the ‘Hate’ Out of Hate Crimes: Applying Unfair Advantage Theory to Justify the Enhanced Punishment of Opportunistic Bias CrimesUCLA Law Review56489
Wolf-Devine, Celia1993Cahn
Yoo, Margaret Y. K.1997Reaffirming Merit in Affirmative ActionJournal of Legal Education37514