The Trouble with Terror

Liberty, Security and the Response to Terrorism

The Trouble with Terror

What is terrorism and can it ever be defended? Beginning with its definition, proceeding to its possible justifications, and culminating in proposals for contending with and combating it, this book offers a full theoretical analysis of the issue of terrorism. Tamar Meisels argues that, regardless of its professed cause, terrorism is diametrically opposed to the requirements of liberal morality and can only be defended at the expense of relinquishing the most basic of liberal commitments. Meisels opposes those who express sympathy and justification for Islamist (particularly Palestinian) terrorism and terrorism allegedly carried out on behalf of developing nations, but, at the same time, also opposes those who would tolerate any reduction in civil liberties in exchange for greater security. Calling wholeheartedly for a unanimous liberal front against terrorism, this is a strong and provocative attempt to address the tension between liberty and security in a time of terror.


The Trouble with Terror addresses an important and controversial topic without pulling punches, but also without losing sight of scholarly values – it has all the force of a polemic, but without the vices thereof.”
Chris Brown, London School of Economics

“Tami Meisels adds a new and distinctive voice to the debate about terrorism and the relation between security considerations and civil liberties. This book combines an emphatic and hardline condemnation of those who express sympathy for the aims and strategies of terrorism, with a profound grasp of the difficulties associated with many of the tactics - such as targeted assassination or coercive interrogation - that are used in the struggle against terrorism. Above all it is an engaged book – engaged in debate with recent writings on these matters, engaged with the values that are endangered both by terrorism and by the tactics that are used against it, and engaged wholeheartedly with the actual events in Israel and elsewhere that have given rise to these dilemmas.”
Jeremy Waldron, University Professor, NYU Law School

“Tamar Meisels writes about some of the hardest moral/political questions with great philosophical sophistication and historical insight. But what marks this book above all is her luminous common sense.”
Michael Walzer, Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton, New Jersey

'This book offers a theoretical analysis of the issue of terrorism. … this is a strong and provocative attempt to address the tension between liberty and security.' Oxfam: Development Resources Review

Aristotle (1976), The Nicomachean Ethics, London: Penguin.
Austin, J. L. (1961), “A Plea for Excuses,” in J. O. Urmson and G. J. Warnock (eds.), Philosophical Papers, Oxford University Press: pp. 123–52.
B'tselem – The Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the “Occupied Territories,”
Barry, John, Michael Hirsh, and Michael Isikoff (2004), “The Roots of Torture – The road to Abu Ghraib began after 9/11, when Washington wrote new rules to fight a new kind of war: A Newsweek investigation,” Newsweek, May 24.
Barzilai, Gad, “Islands of Silence: Democracies Kill?” paper presented at the annual meeting of the Law and Society Association, Budapest, 2000.
Becker, Lawrence C. and Charlotte B. Becker (eds.) (2001), Encyclopedia of Ethics, 2nd edn., New York: Routledge.
Berlin, Isaiah (1990), The Crooked Timber of Humanity: Chapters in the History of Ideas, London: Fontana.
Berman, Paul (2003), Terror and Liberalism, New York and London: Norton.
Borradori, Giovanna (2003), Philosophy in a Time of Terror: Dialogues with Jürgen Habermas and Jacques Derrida, University of Chicago Press.
Bowden, Mark (2003), “The Dark Art of Interrogation” Atlantic Monthly, October: pp. 51–76.
Chomsky, Noam (2001), 9–11, New York: Seven Stories Press.
Coady, C. A. J. (2004), “Terrorism, Morality and Supreme Emergency” Ethics 114 (4): pp. 772–89.
Cohen, Gerald (2003), “Casting the First Stone: Who Can, and Who Can't, Condemn the Terrorists,” in A. O'Hear (ed.), Royal Institute of Philosophy Lectures, 2004–05.
Curzer, H. J. (2006), “Admirable Immorality, Dirty Hands, Ticking Bombs, and Torturing Innocents,” The Southern Journal of Philosophy XLIV: pp. 31–56.
Dan-Cohen, Meir (1984), “Decision Rules and Conduct Rules: On Acoustic Separation in Criminal Law” Harvard Law Review 97: p. 625.
Dan-Cohen, Meir(2002), Harmful Thoughts, Essays on Law, Self and Morality, Princeton University Press.
David, Stephen R. (2003), “Israel's Policy of Targeted Killing,” Ethics and International Affairs 17 (1): pp. 111–26.
Dershowitz, Alan, M. (2002a), Shouting Fire: Civil Liberties in a Turbulent Age, New York: Little, Brown.
Dershowitz, Alan, M. (2002b), Why Terrorism Works: Understanding the Threat, Responding to the Challenge, Yale University Press.
Dershowitz, Alan, M. (2004), “Killing Terrorist Chieftains is Legal,” The Jerusalem Post, April 22: p. 18.
Dershowitz, Alan. M. (1989), “Is It Necessary to Apply ‘Physical Pressure’ to Terrorists – And to Lie About It?” Israel Law Review 23 (2–3): pp. 193–200.
Dworkin, R. (2002), “The Threat to Patriotism,” New York Review of Books, February 28.
Eichensehr, K. E. (2007), “On Target? The Israeli Supreme Court and the Expansion of Targeted Killings,” Yale Law Journal, June 116 (8): pp. 1873, 1875–6.
Finn, J. E. (1991), Constitutions in Crisis: Political Violence and the Rule of Law, Oxford University Press.
Fletcher, George (1978), Rethinking Criminal Law, Boston: Little, Brown.
Fletcher, George (2003), Romantics at War: Glory and Guilt in the Age of Terrorism, Princeton University Press.
Fletcher, George (2006), “The Indefinable Concept of Terrorism” Journal of International Criminal Justice 4 (5): pp. 1–14.
Fletcher, George, “The Problem of Defining Terrorism,” paper presented at Tel-Aviv University at the conference on “Terrorism – Philosophical Perspectives” (organized by the Department of Political Science and the Minerva Center for Human Rights, Tel-Aviv University Law Faculty), March 2004.
Geneva Convention relative to the Treatment of Prisoners of War, adopted on 12 August, 1949,
Gilbert, Paul (2003), New Terror, New Wars, Edinburgh University Press.
Goodin, R. E. (2006), What's Wrong with Terrorism? Cambridge, UK and Malden, MA: Polity Press.
Gross, Michael (2003), “Fighting by Other Means in the Mid-East: A Critical Analysis of Israel's Assassination Policy,” Political Studies 51: pp. 350–68.
Gross, Michael (2004), “Assassination: Killing in the Shadow of Self-Defence,” in J. Irwin (ed.), War and Virtual War: The Challenges of Communities, Amsterdam and New York: Rodopi.
Hague Convention, October 18, 1907,
Hamilton A. (1787), “The Necessity of a Government as Energetic as the One Proposed to the Preservation of the Union”, no. xxiii, New York Packet, Tuesday, December 18, in The Federalist Papers.
Harel, A., “Is Terrorism a Moral Category”, paper presented at Tel-Aviv University at the conference on “Terrorism – Philosophical Perspectives” (organized by the Department of Political Science and the Minerva Center for Human Rights, Tel-Aviv University Law Faculty), March 2004.
HCJ 769/02 (December 11 2005),
Hobbes, T. (1991), Leviathan, ed. R. Tuck, Cambridge University Press.
Honderich, T. (2002), After the Terror, Edinburgh University Press.
Honderich, T. (2003), Terrorism for Humanity: Inquiries in Political Philosophy, London: Pluto Press.
Hornby, A. S. (1991), Oxford Student's Dictionary for Hebrew Speakers, Tel-Aviv: Kernerman.
Ignatieff, Michael (2004), The Lesser Evil: Political Ethics in an Age of Terror, Princeton University Press.
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), adopted December 16 (1966),
Jackson J. (1949), in Terminiello v. City of Chicago, 337 US 1.
Jackson, J. (1963), in Kennedy v. Mendoza-Martinez, 372 US 144.
Kadish, Sanford A. (1989), “Torture, the State and the Individual” Israel Law Review 23: pp. 345–56.
Kamm, Francis M. (2004), “Failure of Just War Theory: Terror, Harm and Justice,” Ethics 114 (4) July.
Kant, Immanuel (1964), Groundwork of the Metaphysic of Morals, trans. H. J. Paton, New York: Harper and Row.
Laqueur, Walter Z. (1987), The Age of Terrorism, Boston: Little, Brown.
Levinson, Sanford (ed.) (2004), Torture – A Collection, Oxford University Press.
Locke J. (1960), Two Treatises of Government, ed. Peter Laslett, Cambridge University Press.
Lukes, Steven (2005), “Liberal Democratic Torture,” British Journal of Political Science 36: pp. 1–16.
Machan, Tibor R. (1990), “Exploring Extreme Violence (Torture),” Journal of Social Philosophy 21: pp. 92–97.
Mackie, J. L. (1990), Ethics – Inventing Right and Wrong, London: Penguin.
Madison, J. (1788), “The Question of a Bill of Rights”, letter to Thomas Jefferson, October 17.
Mavrodes, George I. (1975), “Conventions and the Morality of War,” Philosophy and Public Affairs 4: pp. 117–31.
McMahan, Jeff (2004), “The Ethics of Killing in War,” Ethics 114 (July): pp. 693–733.
McMahan, Jeff (2005), “Just Cause for War,” Ethics and International Affairs 19 (3): pp. 1–13.
Moore, Michael (1989), “Torture and the Balance of Evils,” Israel Law Review 23 (2–3): pp. 280–344.
Nabulsi, Karma (1999), Traditions of War, Oxford University Press.
Nagel, Thomas (1972), “War and Massacre,” Philosophy and Public Affairs, Winter 1 (2): pp. 123–44.
Netanyahu, B. (2001), Fighting Terrorism, 2nd edn., New York: Farrar, Straus, and Giroux.
Netanyahu, B. (ed.) (1986), Terrorism: How the West Can Win, New York: Farrar, Straus, and Giroux.
Nielson, Kai (2000), “There Is No Dilemma of Dirty Hands,” in Paul Rynard and David P. Shugarman (eds.), Cruelty and Deception: The Controversy over Dirty Hands in Politics, Peterborough, Ontario: Broadview Press.
Norman, Richard (1995), Ethics, Killing, and War, Cambridge University Press.
Pape, Robert A. (2003), “The Strategic Logic of Suicide Terrorism,” American Political Science Review 97 (3): pp. 343–61.
Primoratz, Igor (ed.) (2004), Terrorism – The Philosophical Issues, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Protocol I – Addition to the Geneva Conventions (1977), Part IV: Civilian Population,
Public Committee against Torture in Israel, The Supreme Court sitting as the High Court of Justice (draft document) (May 5, 1998, January 13 1999, May 26, 1999) before President A. Barak, Deputy President S. Levin, Justices T. Or, E. Mazza, M. Cheshin, Y. Kedmi, I. Zamir, T. Strasberg-Cohen, D. Dorner,
Rawls, John (1989), A Theory of Justice, 9th edn., Oxford University Press.
Rousseau, Jean Jacques (1993), The Social Contract and Discourses, London and Vermont: Everyman.
Schmid, Alex P. (1984), Political Terrorism: A Research Guide to Concepts, Theories, Data Bases and Literature, Amsterdam: North-Holland Publishing.
Schmid, Alex P. and Albert J. Jongman (1988), Political Terrorism: A Research Guide to Concepts, Theories, Data Bases and Literature, 2nd edn., Amsterdam: North-Holland Publishing.
Shue, Henry (1978), “Torture,” Philosophy and Public Affairs 7 (2): pp. 124–43.
Shue, Henry (1980), Basic Rights: Subsistence, Affluence and US Foreign Policy, Princeton University Press.
Smart, J. and B. Williams (1973), Utilitarianism: For and Against, Cambridge University Press.
Smilansky, Saul (2004), “Terrorism, Justification, and Illusion,” Ethics 114 (4) July: pp. 790–805.
Statman Daniel (2004), “Targeted Killing,” Theoretical Inquiries in Law 5: pp. 179–98.
Statman, Daniel (1997a), “The Absoluteness of the Prohibition against Torture,” Mishpat Umimshal 4: pp. 161–98.
Statman, Daniel (1997b), “Jus in Bello and the Intifada,” in Tomas Kapitan (ed.), Philosophical Perspectives on the Israeli–Palestinian Conflict, Armonk, NY: Sharpe: pp. 133–56.
Statman, Daniel (2003), “The Morality of Assassination: A Response to Gross,” Political Studies 51 (4): pp. 775–9.
Sussman, David (2005), “What's Wrong with Torture?” Philosophy and Public Affairs 33 (1): pp. 1–33.
Twining, W. L. and P. J. Twining (1973), “Bentham on Torture,” Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly 24 (3): pp. 305–56.
United Nations Convention against Torture and Other Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, Part I, Art. 2 (1975),
Waldron, Jeremy (1993), Liberal Rights, Cambridge University Press.
Waldron, Jeremy (2003), “Security and Liberty: The Image of Balance,” The Journal of Political Philosophy 11: pp. 191–210.
Waldron, Jeremy (2004), “Terrorism and the Uses of Terror,” The Journal of Ethics 8: pp. 5–35.
Waldron, Jeremy (2005), “Torture and Positive Law,” Columbia Law Review 105 (6): pp. 1681–750.
Waldron, Jeremy (2006a), “Safety and Security,” Nebraska Law Review 85: pp. 301–53.
Waldron, Jeremy (2007), “Dignity and Rank”, Archives européennes de sociologie 48 (2): pp. 201–37.
Waldron, Jeremy(2006b), “What Can Christian Thinking Add to the Debate about Torture?” Theology Today 63: pp. 330–43.
Walzer, Michael (1973), “Political Action: The Problem of Dirty Hands,” Philosophy and Public Affairs 2 (2): pp. 160–80.
Walzer, Michael (1977), Just and Unjust Wars, New York: Basic Books.
Walzer, Michael (1988), “Terrorism: A Critique of Excuses,” in Steven Luper-Foy (ed.), Problems of International Justice, London: Westview.
Wellman, C. (1979), “On Terrorism Itself,” Journal of Value Inquiry 13: p. 250–2.
Wilkins, B. T. (1992), Terrorism and Collective Responsibility, London: Routledge.
Zohar, Noam J. (1993), “Collective War and Individualistic Ethics: Against the Conscription of Self-Defence,” Political Theory 21: pp. 606–22.
Zuckerman, Adrian A. S. (1989), “Coercion and the Judicial Ascertainment of Truth,” Israel Law Review 23: pp. 357–74.