The Troubled Pregnancy

Legal Wrongs and Rights in Reproduction

The Troubled Pregnancy

Mason looks at the legal response to those aspects of the troubled pregnancy which require or involve medico-legal intervention. The unwanted pregnancy is considered particularly in the light of the Abortion Act 1967, s.1(1)(d) and the related action for so-called wrongful birth due to faulty ante-natal care. The unexpected or uncovenanted birth of a healthy child resulting from failed sterilisation is approached through an analysis of the seminal case of McFarlane and associated cases involving disability in either the neonate or the mother. The disabled neonate's right to sue for its diminished life is discussed and the legal approach to the management of severe congenital disease is analysed - thus following Baroness Hale in believing that care of the newborn is an integral part of pregnancy. Aspects are considered from historical and comparative perspectives, including coverage of experience in the USA, the Commonwealth and Europe.


"The author looks at the legal response to those aspects of troubled pregnancy that require or involve medico-legal intervention....Aspects are considered from historical and comparative perspectives, including coverage of experience in the United States, the Commonwealth, and Europe."
--J.K. Mason, M.D., LL.D., University of Edinburgh, Issues in Law and Medicine, Vol. 24, No.2

Alfirevic, Zarko and James P. Neilson, ‘Antenatal Screening for Down's Syndrome’ (2004) 329 British Medical Journal 811–12
Anonymous, ‘Informed Consent: A Proposed Standard for Medical Disclosure’ (1973) 48 New York University Law Review 548–63
Atiyah, P. S., The Damages Lottery (Oxford: Hart Publishing, 1997)
Bainham, Andrew, ‘Do Babies Have Rights?’ (1997) 56 Cambridge Law Journal 48–50
Balfour-Lynn, Ian M. and Robert C. Tasker, ‘Futility and Death in Paediatric Medical Intensive Care’ (1996) 22 Journal of Medical Ethics 279–81
Baugher, Patricia, ‘Fundamental Protection of a Fundamental Right: Recovery of Child-rearing Damages for Wrongful Pregnancy’ (2000) 75 Washington Law Review 1205–36
BBC News, ‘Cardinal Urges Abortion Rethink’, 21 June 2006 at
Beauchamp, Tom L. and James F. Childress, Principles of Biomedical Ethics (New York: Oxford University Press, 5th edn 2001)
Beaumont, Patricia M. A., ‘Wrongful Life and Wrongful Birth’ in S. A. M. McLean (ed.), Contemporary Issues in Law, Medicine and Ethics (Aldershot: Dartmouth Publishing, 1996), chapter 6
Bickford-Smith, Margaret, ‘Failed Sterilisation Resulting in the Birth of a Disabled Child: The Issues’ (2001) 4 Journal of Personal Injury Law 404–10
Booth, Penny, ‘A Child is a Blessing – Heavily in Disguise, Right?’ (2001) 151 New Law Journal 1738
Boyd, Kenneth, ‘Euthanasia: Back to the Future’ in John Keown (ed.), Euthanasia Examined (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991), chapter 7
Boyle, R. J., R. Salter and M. W. Arnander, ‘Ethics of Refusing Parental Requests to Withhold or Withdraw Treatment from their Premature Baby’ (2004) 30 Journal of Medical Ethics 402–5
Brahams, Diana, ‘Religious Objection versus Parental Duty’ (1993) 342 Lancet 1189–90
Brazier, M., ‘Letting Charlotte Die’ (2004) 30 Journal of Medical Ethics 519–20
Brazier, Margaret and José Miola, ‘Bye-bye Bolam: A Medical Litigation Revolution?’ (2000) 8 Medical Law Review 85–114
Brazier, Margaret, Medicine, Patients and the Law (London: Penguin Books, 3rd edn 2003)
Brazier, Margot, ‘Times of Change?’ (2005) 13 Medical Law Review 1–16
Brazier, Margot,‘Human(s) (as) Medicine(s)’ in Sheila A. M. McLean (ed.), First Do No Harm: Law, Ethics and Health Care (Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing, 2006), chapter 12
British Medical Association, Withholding and Withdrawing Life-prolonging Medical Treatment (London: B.M.A., 2001)
British Medical Association,Parental Responsibility (London, B.M.A., 2004)
Brody, Baruch, Abortion and the Sanctity of Human Life: A Philosophical View (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1985)
Brown, M. T. ‘A Future Like Ours Revisited’ (2002) 28 Journal of Medical Ethics 192–5
Burgermeister, Jane, ‘Doctor Reignites Euthanasia Row in Belgium after Mercy Killing’ (2006) 332 British Medical Journal 382
Callahan, Daniel J., Abortion, Law, Choice and Morality (New York: Macmillan, 1970)
Callus, Thérèse, ‘ “Wrongful Life” a la Francaise’ (2001) 5 Medical Law International 117–26
Cameron, C. and R. Williamson, ‘Is there an Ethical Difference between Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis and Abortion?’ (2003) 29 Journal of Medical Ethics 90–2
Cameron-Perry, J. Ellis, ‘Return of the Burden of the “Blessing” ’ (1999) 149 New Law Journal 1887–8
Campbell, A. G. M. and H. E. McHaffie, ‘Prolonging Life and Allowing Death: Infants’ (1995) 21 Journal of Medical Ethics 339–44
Cane, Peter, ‘Another Failed Sterilisation’ (2004) 120 Law Quarterly Review 189–93
Capron, Alexander Morgan, ‘Tort Liability in Genetic Counselling’ (1979) 79 Columbia Law Review 618–84
Chalmers, Don and Robert Schwartz, ‘Rogers v. Whitaker and Informed Consent in Australia: A Fair Dinkum Duty of Disclosure’ (1993) 1 Medical Law Review 139–59
Clarke, Angus(ed.), Genetic Counselling: Practice and Principles (London, Routledge, 1994)
Clarke, Angus, ‘Is Non-directive Genetic Counselling Possible?’ (1991) 338 Lancet 998–1001
De Garis, C., H. Kuhse, P. Singer and V. Y. Yu, ‘Attitudes of Australian Neonatal Paediatricians to the Treatment of Extremely Preterm Infants’ (1987) 23 Australian Paediatric Journal 223–6
Deliens, Luc, Freddy Mortier, Johan Bilsen et al. ‘End of Life Decisions in Medical Practice in Flanders, Belgium: A Nationwide Survey’ (2000) 356 Lancet 1806–11
Department of Health, A Guide to Consent for Examination or Treatment (HC (90) 22 amended by HSG (9) 32)
Department of Health,Our Inheritance, Our Future (2003), Cm 5791-II
Devaney, Sarah, ‘Autonomy Rules OK’ (2005) 13 Medical Law Review 102–7
Dickens, Bernard, ‘Wrongful Birth and Life, Wrongful Death before Birth and Wrongful law’ in Sheila A. M. McLean (ed.), Legal Issues in Human Reproduction (Aldershot: Dartmouth, 1989), chapter 4
Dixon, Clare, ‘An Unconventional Gloss on Unintended Children’ (2003) 153 New Law Journal 1732–3
Dorozynski, Alexander, ‘Highest French Court Awards Compensation for “Being Born”’ (2001) 323 British Medical Journal 1384
Drife, James Owen, ‘Deregulating Emergency Contraception’ (1993) 307 British Medical Journal 695–6
Duguet, A.M., ‘Wrongful Life: The Recent French Cour de Cassation Decisions’ (2002) 9 European Journal of Health Law 139–49
Dyer, Clare, ‘Gynaecologist Acquitted in Hysterectomy Case’ (1996) 312 British Medical Journal 11–12
Dyer, Clare, ‘HFEA Widens its Criteria for Pre-implantation Genetic Diagnosis’ (2006) 332 British Medical Journal 1174
Earle, Murray, ‘The Future of Informed Consent in British Common Law’ (1999) 6 European Journal of Health Law 235–48
Ferguson, Pamela R., Drug Injuries and the Pursuit of Compensation (London: Sweet & Maxwell, 1996)
Fleming, J. G., The Law of Torts (London: LBC Information Services, 9th edn 1998)
Ford, Norman M., When Did I Begin? (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991)
Fortin, Jane E. S., ‘Is the “Wrongful Life” Action Really Dead?’ [1987] Journal of Social Welfare Law 306–13
Fovargue, Sara and José Miola, ‘Policing Pregnancy: Implications of the Attorney-General's Reference (No. 3 of 1994)’ (1998) 6 Medical Law Review 265–96
Fox, Marie and Jean McHale, ‘In Whose Best Interests?’ (1997) 60 Modern Law Review 700–9
Francome, Colin, Abortion in the USA and the UK (Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing, 2004)
Furedi, Ann, ‘Wrong but the Right Thing to Do: Public Opinion and Abortion’ in Ellie Lee (ed.), Abortion Law and Politics Today (London: Macmillan Press, 1998), chapter 10
General Medical Council, Good Medical Practice (2001)
General Medical Council,Withholding and Withdrawing Life-prolonging Treatments: Good Practice in Decision-making (2002)
Gillam, Lynn, ‘Prenatal Diagnosis and Discrimination against the Disabled’ (1999) 25 Journal of Medical Ethics 163–71
Gillon, Raanan, ‘“Futility” – Too Ambiguous and Pejorative a Term?’ (1997) 23 Journal of Medical Ethics 339–40
Gillon, Raanan, ‘Euthanasia, Withholding Life-prolonging Treatment, and Moral Differences between Killing and Letting Die’ (1988) 14 Journal of Medical Ethics 115–17
Gillon, Raanan, ‘Is there a “new ethics of abortion”?’ (2001) 27 Journal of Medical Ethics supp. II:ii5–ii9
Gledhill, Ruth, ‘Curate Loses Legal Challenge over “Cleft-palate” Abortion’, (2005) The Times, 17 March, p. 14
Golder, Ben, ‘From McFarlane to Melchior and beyond: Love, Sex, Money and Commodification in the Anglo-Australian Law of Torts’ (2004) 12 Torts Law Journal 128
Green, J. M., ‘Obstetricians’ views on Prenatal Diagnosis and Termination of Pregnancy: 1980 Compared with 1993' (1995) 102 British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 228–32
Grey, Alice, ‘Harriton v Stephens: Life, Logic and Legal Fictions’ (2006) 28 Sydney Law Review 545–60
Grubb, Andrew, ‘Abortion Law in England: The Medicalization of a Crime’ (1990) 18 Law, Medicine & Health Care 146–61
Grubb, Andrew, ‘Damages for “Wrongful Conception” ’ (1985) 44 Cambridge Law Journal 30–2
Harris, John, ‘Consent and End of Life Decisions’ (2003) 29 Journal of Medical Ethics 10–15
House of Commons Science and Technology Committee, Human Genetics: The Science and its Consequences, Third Report (1995)
Hoyano, Laura C. H., ‘Misconceptions and Wrongful Conceptions’ (2002) 65 Modern Law Review 883–906
Hugh-Jones, G., ‘Commentary on Taylor v. Shropshire HA’ [2000] Lloyd's Rep Med 107
Huxtable, Richard and Karen Forbes, ‘Glass v. UK: Maternal Instinct v. Medical Opinion’ (2004) 16 Child and Family Law Quarterly 339–54
Jackson, Anthony, ‘Wrongful Life and Wrongful Birth. The English conception’ (1996) 17 Journal of Legal Medicine 349–81
Jackson, Emily, ‘Abortion, Autonomy and Prenatal Diagnosis’ (2000) 9 Social & Legal Studies 467–94
Jackson, EmilyRegulating Reproduction: Law, Technology and Autonomy (Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2001)
Jackson, Mark, ‘Infanticide: Historical Perspectives’ (1996) 146 New Law Journal 416–20
Jotkowitz, A. B. and S. Glick, ‘The Groningen Protocol: Another Perspective’ (2006) 32 Journal of Medical Ethics 157–8
Kashi, Joseph S., ‘The Case of the Unwanted Blessing: Wrongful Life’ (1977) 31 University of Miami Law Review 1409–32
Kennedy, B., ‘The Trend Toward Judicial Recognition of Wrongful Life: A Dissenting View’ (1983) UCLA Law Review 473–501
Kennedy, I. and A. Grubb, Medical Law (London: Butterworths, 3rd edn 2000)
Kennedy, I., ‘Legal and Ethical Implications of Postcoital Birth Control’ in Treat Me Right (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1988), chapter 3
Keown, I. J., ‘ “Miscarriage”: A Medico-Legal Analysis’ [1984] Criminal Law Review 604–14
Keown, J., Abortion, Doctors and the Law (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988)
Keown, John, ‘Reining in the Bolam test’ (1998) 57 Cambridge Law Journal 248–50
Koogler, T. K., B. S. Wilfond and L. F. Ross, ‘Lethal Language, Lethal Decisions’ (2003) 33 Hastings Center Report 37–41
Kuhse, Helga and Peter Singer, Should the Baby Live? (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1985)
Laurie, Graeme T., ‘In Defence of Ignorance: Genetic Information and the Right not to Know’ (1999) 6 European Journal of Health Law 119–32
Law Commission, Report on Injuries to Unborn Children (1974, Law Com. No 60) (Cmd. 5709)
Leading Article ‘Life and Law’ (2004) The Times, 8 October, p. 15
Lewis, Penney, ‘The Necessary Implications of Wrongful Life Claims: Lessons from France’ (2005) 12 European Journal of Health Law 135–52
Lorber, J. and S. A. Salfield, ‘Results of Selective Treatment of Spina Bifida Cystica’ (1981) 56 Archives of Disease in Childhood 822–30
Lorber, J., ‘Ethical Problems in the Management of Myelomeningocele’ (1975) 10 Journal of the Royal College of Physicians of London 47–60
Maclean, Alasdair, ‘Beyond Bolam and Bolitho’ (2002) 5 Medical Law International 205–30
Manninen, A. B., ‘A Case for Justified Non-voluntary Active Euthanasia: Exploring the Ethics of the Groningen Protocol’ (2006) 32 Journal of Medical Ethics 643–51
Marquis, Don, ‘Abortion and the Beginning and End of Human Life’ (2006) 34 Journal of Law and Medical Ethics 16–25
Marquis, Don, ‘Why Abortion is Immoral’ (1989) 86 Journal of Philosophy 183–202
Mason, J. K. and David W. Meyers, ‘Parental Choice and Selective Non-treatment of Deformed Newborns: a View from mid-Atlantic’ (1986) 12 Journal of Medical Ethics 67–71
Mason, J. K. and G. T. Laurie, Mason and McCall Smith's Law and Medical Ethics (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 7th edn 2005)
Mason, J. K. and R. A. McCall Smith, Law and Medical Ethics (Butterworths: London, 1982)
Mason, J. K., ‘A Lords’ Eye View of Fetal Status' (1999) 3 Edinburgh Law Review 246–50
Mason, J. K., ‘Ethical Principles and Ethical Practice’ (2006) 1 Clinical Ethics 3–6
Mason, J. K., ‘From Dundee to Darlington: An End to the McFarlane Line?’ [2004] Juridical Review 365–86
Mason, J. K., ‘Master of the Balancers: Non-Voluntary Therapy under the Mantle of Lord Donaldson’ [1993] Juridical Review 115–32
Mason, J. K., ‘Unwanted Pregnancy: A Case of Retroversion?’ (2000) 4 Edinburgh Law Review 191–206
Mason, J. K., ‘What's in a Name? The Vagaries of Vo v France’ (2005) 17 Child and Family Law Quarterly 97–112
Mason, J. K., ‘Wrongful life: The problem of causation’ (2004) 6 Medical Law International 149–61
Mason, J. K., ‘Wrongful Pregnancy, Wrongful Birth and Wrongful Terminology’ (2002) 6 Edinburgh Law Review 46–66
Mason, J. K.,‘A Turn-up Down Under: McFarlane in the Light of Cattanach’ (2004) 1 SCRIPT-ed, at
Mason, J. K.Medico-Legal Aspects of Reproduction and Parenthood (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2nd edn 1998)
Mason, Kenyon and Douglas Brodie, ‘Bolam, Bolam … Wherefore Art Thou Bolam?’ (2005) 9 Edinburgh Law Review 298–306
McHaffie, Hazel E., Ian A. Laing, Michael Parker and John McMillan, ‘Deciding for Imperilled Newborns: Medical Authority or Parental Autonomy?’ (2001) 27 Journal of Medical Ethics 104–9
McHaffie, Hazel et al., Crucial Decisions at the Beginning of Life (Oxford: Radcliffe Medical Press, 2001)
McLean, S. A. M. and J. K. Mason, Legal and Ethical Aspects of Healthcare (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2003)
McLean, Sheila A. M. and J. Kenyon Mason, ‘Our Inheritance, Our Future: Their Rights?’ (2005) 13 International Journal of Children's Rights 255–72
McLean, Sheila A. M., ‘Abortion Law: Is Consensual Reform Possible?’ (1990) 17 Journal of Law and Society 106–23
McLean, Sheila A. M., A Patient's Right to Know: Information Disclosure, the Doctor and the Law (Aldershot: Dartmouth, 1989)
McLean, Sheila, Old Law, New Medicine (London: Pandora Press, 1999)
Meyers, David W., ‘Wyatt and Winston-Jones: Who Decides to Treat or Let Die Seriously Ill Babies?’ (2005) 9 Edinburgh Law Review 307–16
Meyers, David, ‘Chester v. Afshar: Sayonara, Sub Silentio, Sidaway?’ in Sheila A. M. McLean (ed.), First Do No Harm (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2006), chapter 16
Miola, José, ‘Autonomy Rued OK?’ (2006) 14 Medical Law Review 108–14
Morris, Anne and Severine Saintier, ‘To Be Or Not To Be: Is That The Question? Wrongful Life and Misconceptions’ (2003) 11 Medical Law Review 167–93
Mueller, Robert F. and Ian D. Young, Emery's Elements of Medical Genetics (Edinburgh, Churchill Livingstone, 11th edn 2001)
Muramoto, Osamu, ‘Bioethical Aspects of the Recent Changes in the Policy of Refusal of Blood by Jehovah's Witnesses’ (2001) 322 British Medical Journal 37–9
Norrie, Kenneth McK., ‘Damages for the Birth of a Child’ 1985 Scots Law Times 69–74
Norrie, Kenneth, ‘Post-Coital anti-pregnancy techniques and the law’ in A. Allan Templeton and Douglas Cusine (eds.), Reproductive Medicine and the Law (Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone, 1990), chapter 2
Nuffield Council on Bioethics, Genetic Screening: Ethical Issues (1993)
Nys, H. F. L. and J. C. J. Dute, ‘A Wrongful Existence in the Netherlands’ (2004) 30 Journal of Medical Ethics 393–4
O'Donovan, Katherine and Roy Gilbar, ‘The Loved Ones: Families, Intimates and Patient Autonomy’ (2003) 23 Legal Studies 332–58
O'Donovan, Katherine, ‘Taking a Neutral Stance on the Legal Protection of the Fetus’ (2006) 14 Medical Law Review 115–23
O'Donovan, Katherine, ‘The Medicalisation of Infanticide’ [1984] Criminal Law Review 259–64
O'Neill, Onora, Autonomy and Trust in Bioethics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002)
Otlowski, Margaret, Voluntary Euthanasia and the Common Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000)
Pace, P. J. ‘Civil Liability for Pre-natal Injury’ (1977) 40 Modern Law Review 141–58
Pancevski, Bojan, ‘Doctor Must Pay Child Support after Inadequate Warning of Disability’ (2006) 333 British Medical Journal 168
Pedain, Antje, ‘Unconventional Justice in the House of Lords’ (2004) 63 Cambridge Law Journal 19–21
Perry, Michael J., Under God? (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003)
Pijnemborg, L., P. J. van der Maas, J. J. M. van Delden and C. W. M. Looman, ‘Life Terminating Acts without Explicit Request of Patient’ (1993) 341 Lancet 1196–9
Plomer, Aurora, ‘A Foetal Right to Life? The Case of Vo v France’ (2005) 5 Human Rights Law Review 311–36
Pradel, Jean, ‘Violences involontaires sur femme enceinte et délit d'homicide involontaire’ (2004) 7/7148 Recueil Dalloz 449–50
Priaulx, Nicky, ‘Parental Disability and Wrongful Conception’ [2003] Family Law 117–20
Priaulx, Nicky, ‘That's One Heck of an “Unruly Horse”! Riding Roughshod over Autonomy in Wrongful Conception’ (2004) 12 Feminist Legal Studies 317–31
Priaulx, Nicolette M., ‘Damages for the “Unwanted” Child: Time for a Rethink?’ (2005) 73 Medico-Legal Journal 152–63
Radley-Gardner, Oliver, ‘Wrongful Birth Revisited’ (2002) 118 Law Quarterly Review 11–15
Rogers, Lois, ‘Fifty Babies a Year are Alive after Abortion’ (2005) Sunday Times, 27 November
Rotkin, Jeffrey R. and Maxwell J. Mehlman, ‘Wrongful Birth: Medical, Legal and Philosophical Issues’ (1994) 22 Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 21–8
Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, Termination of Pregnancy for Fetal Abnormality in England, Wales and Scotland (1996)
Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, The Care of Women Requesting Induced Abortion: Guideline (2000)
Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, Withholding or Withdrawing Life Sustaining Treatment in Children: A Framework for Practice (2nd edn 2004)
Rudman, Stanley, Concepts of Person and Christian Ethics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997)
Russell, Eleanor J., ‘Is Parenthood an “Unblemished Blessing” in Every Case?’ 1998 Scots Law Times 191–7
Sanger, Carol, ‘Regulating Teenage Abortion in the United States’ (2004) 18 International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family 305–18
Savulescu, J., ‘Abortion, Embryo Destruction and the Future of Value Argument’ (2002) 28 Journal of Medical Ethics 133–5
Schneiderman, L. J. and N. Jecker, ‘Futility in Practice’ (1993) 153 Archives of Internal Medicine 437–41
Scott, Rosamund, ‘The English Fetus and the Right to Life’ (2004) 11 European Journal of Health Law 347–64
Seneviratne, Mary, ‘Pre-natal Injury and Transferred Malice: The Invented Other’ (1996) 59 Modern Law Review 884–92
Shapira, Amos, ‘ “Wrongful life” Lawsuits for Faulty Genetic Counselling: Should the Impaired Newborn be Entitled to Sue?’ (1998) 24 Journal of Medical Ethics 369–75
Sheldon, Sally and Stephen Wilkinson, ‘Termination of Pregnancy for Reasons of Foetal Disability: Are There Grounds for a Special Exception in Law?’ (2001) 9 Medical Law Review 85–109
Sheldon, Tony, ‘Court awards Damages to Disabled Child for Having Been Born’ (2003) 326 British Medical Journal 784
Sheldon, Tony, ‘Dutch Supreme Court Backs Damages for Child for Having Been Born’ (2005) 330 British Medical Journal 747
Sheldon, Tony, ‘Killing or Caring?’ (2005) 330 British Medical Journal 560
Sheldon, Tony, ‘The Netherlands Regulates Ending the Lives of Severely Ill Neonates’ (2005) 331 British Medical Journal 1357
Singer, Peter, Rethinking Life and Death (New York: St. Martin's Press, 1995)
Singer, S., ‘Rees v. Darlington Memorial Hospital NHS Trust [2004] 1 AC 309’ [2004] 26 Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law 403–15
Smith, J. C., D. Cranston, T. O'Brien et al., ‘Fatherhood without Apparent Spermatozoa after Vasectomy’ (1994) 344 Lancet 30
Spriggs, M. and J. Savulescu, ‘The Perruche Judgment and the “Right Not to Be Born”’ (2002) 28 Journal of Medical Ethics 63–4
Steinbock, Bonnie, Life before Birth: The Moral and Legal Status of Embryos and Fetuses (New York: Oxford University Press, 1992).
Stewart, Angus, ‘Damages for the Birth of a Child’ (1995) 40 Journal of the Law Society of Scotland 298–302
Stirrat, G. M. and R. Gill, ‘Autonomy in Medical Ethics after O'Neill’ (2005) 31 Journal of Medical Ethics 127–30
Strasser, Mark, ‘Yes, Virginia, There Can Be Wrongful Life: On Consistency, Public Policy, and the Birth-Related Torts’ (2004) 4 Georgetown Journal of Gender and Law 821–61
Stretton, Dean, ‘The Birth Torts: Damages for Wrongful Birth and Wrongful Life’ (2005) 10 Deakin Law Review 310–64
Suter, Sonia Mateu, ‘The Routinization of Prenatal Testing’ (2002) 28 American Journal of Law and Medicine 233–70
Teff, Harvey, ‘The Action for “Wrongful Life” in England and the United States’ (1985) 34 International and Comparative Law Quarterly 423–41
Temkin, Jennifer, ‘Pre-natal Injury, Homicide and the Draft Criminal Code’ (1986) 45 Cambridge Law Journal 414–29
Templeton, Sarah-Kate and Lois Rogers, ‘Babies that Live after Abortion Are Left to Die’ (2004) The Sunday Times, 20 June, p. 1.3
Templeton, Sarah-Kate, ‘Doctors: Let Us Kill Disabled Babies’ (2006) Sunday Times, 5 November, p. 1.1
Thomson, Joe, ‘Abandoning the Law of Delict?’ 2000 Scots Law Times 43–5
Thomson, Judith Jarvis, ‘A Defense of Abortion’ (1971) 1 Philosophy and Public Affairs 47–66
Tingle, J. H., ‘Do Guidelines Have Legal Implications?’ (2002) 86 Archives of Disease in Childhood 387–8
Todd, Stephen, ‘Wrongful Conception, Wrongful Birth and Wrongful Life’ (2005) 27 Sydney Law Review 525–42
Tooley, Michael, ‘In Defense of Abortion and Infanticide’ in J. Feinberg (ed.), The Problem of Abortion (Belmont: Wadsworth, 1973), pp. 83–114
Tooley, Michael, Abortion and Infanticide (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1983)
Treneman, A., ‘Sex and Relationships Muddy the Debate’ (2005) The Times, 20 July, p. 28
Trotzig, Marten A., ‘The Defective Child and the Actions for Wrongful Life and Wrongful Birth’ (1980) 14 Family Law Quarterly 15–40
Tunkel, Victor, ‘Modern Anti-Pregnancy Techniques and the Criminal Law’ [1974] Criminal Law Review 461–71
Verhagen, Eduard and Pieter J. J. Sauer, ‘The Groningen Protocol – Euthanasia in Severely Ill Newborns’ (2005) 352 New England Journal of Medicine 959–62
Verkuyl, Douwe A. A., ‘Two World Religions and Family Planning’ (1993) 342 Lancet 473–5
Wald, N. J., H. C. Watt and A. K. Hackshaw, ‘Integrated Screening for Down's Syndrome on the Basis of Tests Performed During the first and Second Trimesters’ (1999) 341 New England Journal of Medicine 461–7
Walker, C. H., ‘… Officiously to Keep Alive’ 63 Archives of Disease in Childhood 560–6
Warden, John, ‘Abortion and Conscience’ (1990) 301 British Medical Journal 1013
Warnock, Dame Mary (Chairman), Report of the Committee of Inquiry into Human Fertilisation and Embryology (1984), Cmd. 9314
Watson, Penelope, ‘Wrongful Life Actions in Australia’ (2002) 26 Melbourne University Law Review 736–49
Weir, Robert F., Selective Non-treatment of Handicapped Newborns (New York: Oxford University Press, 1984)
Weir, Tony, ‘The Unwanted Child’ (2000) 59 Cambridge Law Journal 238–41
Weir, Tony, ‘The Unwanted Child’ (2002) 6 Edinburgh Law Review 244–53
Wennberg, R. N., Life in the Balance (Grand Rapids: W. B. Eerdmans, 1985)
Whitelaw, Andrew, ‘Death as an Option in Neonatal Intensive Care’ (1986) 328 Lancet 328–31
Whitfield, Adrian, ‘Common Law Duties to Unborn Children’ (1993) 1 Medical Law Review 28–52
Wicks, Elizabeth, Michael Wyldes and Mark Kilby, ‘Late Termination of Pregnancy for Fetal Abnormality: Medical and Legal Perspectives’ (2004) 12 Medical Law Review 285–305
Wilkinson, D., ‘Is it in the Best Interests of an Intellectually Disabled Infant to Die?’ (2006) 32 Journal of Medical Ethics 454–9
Williams, Glanville, Textbook of Criminal Law (London: Stevens & Sons, 2nd edn 1983)
Woolley, S., ‘Children of Jehovah's Witnesses and Adolescent Jehovah's Witnesses: What are their Rights?’ (2005) 90 Archives of Disease in Childhood 715–19
Wyatt, John, ‘Medical Paternalism and the Fetus’ (2001) 27 Journal of Medical Ethics suppl. II:ii15–ii20
Zucker, Marjorie B. and Howard D. Zucker (eds.), Medical Futility (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997)