The Divine Sense

The Intellect in Patristic Theology

The Divine Sense

A. N. Williams examines the conception of the intellect in patristic theology from its beginnings in the work of the Apostolic Fathers to Augustine and Cassian in the early fifth century. The patristic notion of intellect emerges from its systematic relations to other components of theology: the relation of human mind to the body and the will; the relation of the human to the divine intellect; of human reason to divine revelation and secular philosophy; and from the use of the intellect in both theological reflection and spiritual contemplation. The patristic conception of that intellect is therefore important for the way it signals the character of early Christian theology as both systematic and contemplative and as such, distinctive in its approach from secular philosophies of its time and modern Christian theology.


"Williams writes in a refreshingly direct style...Her own voice rarely intrudes in the body of the text, but when it does, she offers acute judgments and nice insights." --Carl N. Still, St. Thomas More College

Špidlík, Thomas. 1971. Grégoire de Nazianze: introduction à l’étude de sa doctrine spirituelle. (Orientalia Christiana Analecta; 189). Rome: Pont. Institutum Studiorum Orientalium.
Ackrill, J. L. 1981. Aristotle the Philosopher. Oxford: Clarendon.
Armstrong, A. H. 1967. The Cambridge History of Later Greek and Early Medieval Philosophy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Armstrong, A. H. 1979. Plotinian and Christian Studies. London: Variorum. (Reprints of essays dated 1936–77.)
Armstrong, A. H. 3rd ed. 1977. An Introduction to Ancient Philosophy. London: Methuen. [s.l.]: Littlefield, Adams (rpt.).
Ayers, Robert H. 1979. Language and Reason in the Church Fathers. (Altertumswissenschaftliche Texte und Studien; 6). Hildesheim: Georg Olms.
Böhm, Thomas. 1996. Theoria, Unendlichkeit, Aufsteig: Philosophische Implikationen zu De vita Moysis von Gregor von Nyssa. (Supplements to Vigiliae Christianae; 35). Leiden: Brill.
Balthasar, Hans Urs von. 1988. Presence and Thought: an Essay on the Religious Thought of Gregory of Nyssa. Tr. Mark Sebanc. San Francisco: Ignatius, 1995. French original: Présence et pensée: Essai sur la philosophie religieuse de Grégoire de Nysse. Paris: Beauchesne.
Bamberger, John Eudes. 1992. ‘Desert Calm Evagrius Ponticus [sic]: the Theologian as Spiritual Guide’. Cistercian Studies 27: 185–98.
Barnard, L. W. 1967. Justin Martyr: His Life and Thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Barnes, Timothy David. 1971. Tertullian: A Historical and Literary Study. Oxford: Clarendon.
Battenhouse, Roy W. ed., 1955. A Companion to the Study of St. Augustine. New York: Oxford University Press.
Bavel, T. J. van. 1998. ‘God in between Affirmation and Negation According to Augustine’, in Leinhard 1998, 73–97.
Bebis, George S. 1966–67. ‘Gregory of Nyssa's “De Vita Moysis”: a Philosophical and Theological Analysis’. Greek Orthodox Theological Review 12: 369–93.
Behr, John. 2000. Asceticism and Anthropology in Irenaeus and Clement. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Berchman, Robert. 1992. ‘Origen on The Categories: A Study in Later Platonic First Principles’, in Daly 1992, 231–52.
Bergman, Sigurd. 1995. Geist, der Natur befreit: die trinitarische kosmologie Gregors von Nazianz im Horizont einer ökologischen Theologie der Befreiung. Mainz: Matthias-Grünewald.
Bertrand, Dominique. 1999. ‘L’Implication du nous dans la prière chez Origène et Évagre le Pontique’. In Bienert 1999, 355–64.
Bienert, W. A. and U. Kühneweg eds. 1999. Origeniana Septima: Origenes in den Auseinandersetzungen des 4. Jahrhunderts. (Bibliotheca ephemeridium theologorum lovaniensum; 137). Leuven: Leuven University Press.
Bourassa F. 1977. ‘Théologie trinitaire chez Saint Augustin’. Gregorianum [Part I] 58: 675–725.
Bourassa F. 1978. ‘Théologie trinitaire chez Saint Augustin’. Gregorianum [Part II] 59: 375–412.
Bouyer, Louis. 1960. The Spirituality of the New Testament and the Fathers, tr. Mary P. Ryan. (History of Christian Spirituality; 1). London: Burns & Oates. (French ed.: La Spiritualité du Nouveau Testament et des Pères. Paris: Editions Montaigne.)
Brakke, David. 1995. Athanasius and Asceticism. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. (Rpt of Athanasius and the Politics of Asceticism. New York: Oxford University Press.)
Bunge, Gabriel. 1988. Geistliche Vaterschaft: Christliche Gnosis bei Evagrios Ponticos. (Studia Patristica et liturgica; 23). Regensburg: Friedrich Pustet.
Burnaby, John. 1938. Amor Dei: A Study of the Religion of St. Augustine. London: Hodder and Stoughton.
Burton-Christie, Douglas. 1993. The Word in the Desert: Scripture and the Quest for Holiness in Early Christian Monasticism. New York: Oxford University Press.
Butler, Dom Cuthbert. 1924. Western Mysticism: The Teaching of SS. Augustine, Gregory and Bernard on the Contemplative Life. New York: Dutton.
Cavadini, John. 1992. ‘The Structure and Intention of Augustine's De Trinitate’. Augustinian Studies 23: 103–23.
Cavarnos, John. 1955. ‘Gregory of Nyssa on the Nature of the Soul’. Greek Orthodox Theological Review 1: 133–41.
Cavarnos, John. 1976. ‘The Relation of Body and Soul in the Thought of Gregory of Nyssa’, in Dörrie, 61–78.
Chadwick, Henry. 1966. Early Christian Thought and the Classical Tradition: Studies in Justin, Clement, and Origen. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Chadwick, Owen. 1968. John Cassian. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 2nd ed.
Clark, Mary T. 1998. ‘Augustine on Person: Divine and Human’, in Leinhard 1998, 99–120.
Collinge, William J. 1987. ‘De Trinitate and the Understanding of Religious Language’. Augustinian Studies 18: 126–50.
Cooper, John C. 1984. ‘The Basic Philosophical and Theological Notions of Saint Augustine’. Augustinian Studies 15: 93–113.
Cox, Patricia. 1985. ‘Origen and the Bestial Imagination’, in Hansen 1985, 65–69.
Crouzel, Henri. ‘Seminar III: Origène et Plotin’, in Lies 1987, 430–35.
Crouzel, Henri. 1985. ‘La Personnalité d’Origène’, in Hansen 1985, 9–25.
Crouzel, Henri. 1987. ‘L’Apocatastase chez Origène’, in Lies 1987, 282–90.
Crouzel, Henri. 1989. Origen. tr. A. S. Worrall. Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark. (French ed: Origène. Paris: Editions Lethielleux, 1985.)
Crouzel, Henri. 1995. ‘Le Contexte spirituel de l’exégèse dite spirituelle’, in Dorival 1995, 333–42.
Cushman, Robert E. 1955. ‘Faith and Reason’, in Battenhouse 1955, 287–314.
Dörrie, Heinrich, Margarete Altenburger and Uta Schramm, eds. 1976. Gregor von Nyssa und die Philosophie. (2nd International Colloquium on Gregory of Nyssa). Leiden: Brill.
Daly, Robert ed. 1992. Origeniana Quinta. (Bibliotheca ephemeridium theologorum lovaniensum; 105). Leuven: Leuven University Press.
Daniélou, Jean. 1953. Platonisme et théologie mystique: Doctrine spirituelle de Saint Grégoire de Nysse. 2nd ed. (Théologie; 2). Aubier: Editions Montaigne.
Daniélou, Jean. 1955. Origen. Tr. Walter Mitchell. London: Sheed & Ward. (French ed: Origène. Paris: La Table Ronde, 1948.)
Daniélou, Jean. 1970. L’Être et le temps chez Grégoire de Nysse. Leiden: Brill.
Daniels, Donald E. 1977. ‘The Argument of the De Trinitate and Augustine's Theory of Signs’. Augustinian Studies 8: 33–54.
De Mello, Anthony. 1984. Sadhana: a Way to God. Garden City, NY: Image/Doubleday. (Originally published Poona, [s.n.], 1978).
Dempf, Alois. 1970. ‘Evagrios Ponticos als Metaphysiker und Mystiker’. Philosophisches Jahrbuch im Auftrag der Görres-Gesellschaft 77: 297–319.
Dillon, John. ‘Origen's Doctrine of the Trinity and Some Later Neoplatonic Theories’, in O’Meara 1982, 19–23.
Dorival, Gilles. 1987. ‘Origène et la Résurrection de la Chair’, in Lies 1987, 291–321.
Dorival, Gilles. and Alain LeBolluec eds. 1995. Origeniana Sexta: Origène et la Bible. (Bibliotheca ephemeridium theologirum lovaniensum; 118). Leuven: Leuven University Press.
Ellverson, Anna-Stina. 1981. The Dual Nature of Man: a Study in the Theological Anthropology of Gregory of Nazianzus. (Acta Universitatis Uppsaliensis; Studia Doctrinae Christianae Upsaliensia; 21). Uppsala: [s.n.].
Festugière, A. J. 1936. Contemplation et vie contemplative selon Platon. (Bibliothèque de philosophie; 2). Paris: Vrin.
Forsyth, P. T. The Soul of Prayer. London: C. H. Kelly, 1916.
Gilson, Étienne. 1960. The Christian Philosophy of Saint Augustine, tr. L. E. M. Lynch. New York: Random House.
Goodenough, Erwin R. 1923. The Theology of Justin Martyr. Jena: Fromansche Buchhandlung.
Hansen, R. P. C. and Henri Crouzel, eds. [1985.] Origeniana Tertia. [s.l.]: Edizioni dell’Ateneo.
Harrison, Verna E. F. 1989. ‘Receptacle Imagery in St. Gregory of Nyssa's Anthropology’. Studia Patristica 22: 23–27.
Harrison, Verna E. F. 1992. Grace and Human Freedom According to St. Gregory of Nyssa. (Studies in the Bible and Early Christianity; 30). Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen.
Heine, Ronald E. 1975. Perfection in the Virtuous Life: a Study in the Relationship between Edification and Polemical Theology in Gregory of Nyssa's Life of Moses. (Patristic Monograph Series; 2). Cambridge, MA: Philadelphia Patristic Foundation.
Hill Edmund. 1984. ‘Unless You Believe, You Shall Not Understand: Augustine's Perception of Faith’. Augustinian Studies 25: 51–63.
Hill, Edmund. 1971. ‘Karl Rahner's Remarks on the Dogmatic Treatise De Trinitate and St. Augustine’. Augustinian Studies 2: 67–80.
Hoitenga, Dewey. 1998. ‘Faith Seeks Understanding: Augustine's Alternative to Natural Theology’, in Leinhard, 1998, 295–304.
Hussey, Edward. 1972. The Presocratics. (Classical Life and Letters). London: Duckworth.
Jaeger, Werner. 1961. Early Christianity and Greek Paideia. Cambridge, MA: Belknap/Harvard University Press.
Kobusch, Theo. 1987. ‘Das Christentum als die wahre Philosophie’, in Lies 1987, 442–46.
LaCugna, Catherine Mowry, 1991. God for Us: The Trinity and Christian Life. San Francisco: Harper.
Lear, Jonathan. 1988. Aristotle: the Desire to Understand. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Leclerq, Jean. 1961. The Love of Learning and the Desire for God: a Study of Monastic Culture, tr. Catherine Misrahi. New York: Fordham. (French ed.: Paris: Cerf, 1957.)
Lefeber, P. S. A. 1999. ‘The Same View on Prayer in Origen's Sermons and His Treatise on Prayer’, in Bienert 1999, 33–38.
Leinhard, Joseph C., Earl C. Muller and Ronald J. Teske, eds. 1993. Augustine: Presbyter Factus Sum, (Collectanea Augustiniana.) New York: Peter Lang.
Leys, Roger. 1951. L’Image de Dieu chez Saint Grégoire de Nysse: Esquisse d’une doctrine. (Museum Lessianum; Section Théologique, no. 49). Brussels: L’Edition Universelle.
Lies, Lothar ed. 1987. Origeniana Quarta. (Innsbrucker theologische Studien; 19). Innsbruck: Tyrolia-Verlag.
Lloyd, A. C., 1972. ‘On Augustine's Concept of a Person’, in Markus 1972, 191–205.
Lonergan, Bernard. 1974. ‘The Depersonalization of Dogma’, in A Second Collection, eds. William F. Ryan and Bernard J. Tyrrell. Philadelphia: Westminster.
Louth, Andrew. 1986. ‘Augustine’ in The Study of Spirituality, eds. Cheslyn Jones, Geoffrey Wainwright and Edward Yarnold. New York: Oxford University Press, 134–45.
Louth, Andrew. 1987. Introduction to Early Christian Writings (see Apostolic Fathers, under Primary Texts).
Louth, Andrew1981. The Origins of the Christian Mystical Tradition: From Plato to Denys. Oxford: Clarendon.
Ludlow, Morwenna. 2000. Universal Salvation; Eschatology in the Thought of Gregory of Nyssa and Karl Rahner. (Oxford Theological Monographs). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Mühlenberg, Ekkehard. 1966. Die Unendlichkeit Gottes bei Gregor von Nyssa: Gregors Kritik am Gottesbegriff der klassischen Metaphysik. (Forschungen zur Kirchen- und Dogmengeschichte; 16). Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.
Markus, R. A., ed. 1972. Augustine: A Collection of Critical Essays. (Modern Studies in Philosophy). Garden City, NY: Anchor.
Maschke, Timothy. 1998. ‘Augustine's Theology of Prayer: Gracious Conformation’, in Leinhard, 1998, 431–46.
McGuckin, John A. 2001. St. Gregory of Nazianzus: an Intellectual Biography. Crestwood, NY: St. Vladimir's.
McLelland, Joseph C. 1976. God the Anonymous: a Study in Alexandrian Philosophical Theology. (Patristic Monograph Series; 4). Cambridge, MA: Philadelphia Patristic Foundation.
Meredith, A. 1989. ‘The Concept of Mind in Gregory of Nyssa and the Neoplatonists’. Studia Patristica 22: 35–51.
Merton, Thomas. 1962. New Seeds of Contemplation. New York: New Directions 1961.
Merton, Thomas1973. Contemplative Prayer. London: Orton, Longman and Todd.
Mueller, Earl C. 1998. ‘The Priesthood of Christ in Book IV of the De Trinitate’, in Leinhard 1998, 135–49.
Musser, Donald W. and Joseph L. Price, eds. 1996. A New Handbook of Theologians. Nashville: Abington.
Nash, Ronald A. 1969. The Light of the Mind: St. Augustine's Theory of Knowledge. Lexington, KY: University Press of Kentucky.
Noel, Virginia L. 1992. ‘Nourishment in Origen's On Prayer’. In Daly 1992, 481–87.
Norris, Richard A. 1965. God and the World in Early Christian Theology: A Study in Justin Martyr, Irenaeus, Tertullian and Origen. (Studies in Patristic Thought). London: Adam and Charles Black.
Nussbaum, Martha. 1994. The Therapy of Desire: Theory and Practice of Hellenistic Ethics. (Martin Classical Lectures; n.s. 2). Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
O’Cleirigh, Padraigh. 1987. ‘Knowledge of the Word in Origen’, in Lies 1987, 349–51.
O’Connell, Patrick F. 1983. ‘The Double Journey of Saint Gregory of Nyssa: The Life of Moses’. Greek Orthodox Theological Review 28: 301–24.
O’Connell, Robert J. 1972. ‘Action and Contemplation’, in Markus, 1972, 38–58.
O’Driscoll, Jeremy. 1990. ‘A Key for Reading the Ad Monachos of Evagrius Ponticus’. Augustinianum 30: 361–92.
O’Hagan, Angelo. 1968. Material Re-Creation in the Apostolic Fathers. (Texte und Untersuchungen zur Geschichte der Altchristlichen Literatur; 100). Berlin: Akademie Verlag.
O’Meara, Dominic J., ed. 1982. Neoplatonism and Christian Thought. (Studies in Neoplatonism; 3). Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
Osborn, Eric. 1987. ‘Causality in Plato and Origen’, in Lies 1987, 362–69.
Osborn, Eric. 1992. ‘Origen: the Twentieth Century Quarrel and Its Recovery’, in Daly 1992, 26–39.
Osborn, Eric. 1997. Tertullian, First Theologian of the West. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Osborn, Eric. 2001. Irenaeus of Lyons. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Pépin, Jean. 1971. Idées grecques sur l’homme et sur Dieu. Paris: Les Belles Lettres.
Pépin, Jean. 1982. ‘The Platonic and the Christian Ulysses’, in O’Meara 1982, 3–18.
Patterson, L. G. 1967. God and History in Early Christian Thought: A Study of Themes from Justin Martyr to Gregory the Great. (Studies in Patristic Thought). London: Adam and Charles Black.
Plagnieux, Jean. 1951. Saint Grégoire de Nazianze théologien. (Études de science religieuse; 7). Paris: Editions Franciscaines. [n.d.; imprimatur 1951].
Quasten, Johannes. 1950. Patrology. Vol 1: The Beginnings of Patristic Literature. Westminster, MD: Christian Classics. (Rpt).
Rist, John. 1994. Augustine: Ancient Thought Baptized. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Roberts, Robert E. 1924. The Theology of Tertullian. London: Epworth.
Roukema, Riemer. 1999. ‘Nicht die Philosophie, sondern die Hoffnung and die Liebe haben bei Origenes das letzte Wort: “Dei Liebe komme nie zu Fall” (1 Kor 13,8A) als Argument des Origenes gegen einem neuen Abfall der Seelen von Gott’, in Bienert 1999, 15–24.
Rowe, J. N. 1985. ‘The Eventual Reconciling of Human Beings to the Father by Christ, and His Consequent Subjugation to the Father’, in Hansen 1985, 139–50.
Ruether, Rosemary Radford. 1969. Gregory of Nazianzus: Rhetor and Philosopher. Oxford; Clarendon.
Somos, Róbert. 1999. ‘Origen, Evagrios Ponticos and the Ideal of Impassibility’, in Bienert 1999, 365–74.
Stead, Christopher. 1982. ‘The Concept of Mind and the Concept of God in the Christian Fathers’, in The Philosophical Frontiers of Theology: Essays Presented to D. M. MacKinnon, eds. Brian Hebblethwaite and Stewart Sutherland. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 39–54.
Stewart, Columba. 1998. Cassian the Monk. (Oxford Studies in Historical Theology). New York: Oxford University Press.
Stewart, Columba. 2001. ‘Imageless Prayer and the Theological Vision of Evagrius Ponticus’. Journal of Early Christian Studies 9: 173–204.
Stritzky, Maria-Barbara. 1973. Zum Problem der Erkenntnis bei Gregor von Nyssa. (Münsterische Beiträge zur Theologie; 37). Münster: Aschendorff.
Torjesen, Karen J. 1987. ‘Pedagogical Soteriology from Clement to Origen’, in Lies 1987, 370–78.
Trigg, Joseph. 1992. ‘Origen, Man of the Church’, in Daly 1992, 51–56.
Völker, Walther. 1955. Gregor von Nyssa als Mystiker. Wiesbaden: Franz Steiner.
Wainwright, Geoffrey. 1980. Doxology: the Praise of God in Worship, Doctrine and Life. New York: Oxford University Press.
Wallis, R. T. 1972. Neoplatonism. London: Duckworth. (2nd ed. 1995).
Widdicombe, Peter. 1994. The Fatherhood of God from Origen to Athanasius. Oxford: Clarendon.
Wilken, Robert Louis. 2003. The Spirit of Early Christian Thought: Seeking the Face of God. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Williams, Rowan. 1985. ‘Origen on the Soul of Jesus’, in Hansen 1985, 131–37.
Williams, Rowan. 1998. ‘The Paradoxes of Self-Knowledge in the De Trinitate’, in Leinhard 1998, 121–34.
Wingren, Gustaf. 1947. Man and the Incarnation: A Study in the Biblical Theology of Irenaeus, tr. Ross Mackenzie. Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd, 1959. (Swedish ed: Lund: Gleerup, 1947.)
Winslow, Donald F. 1979. The Dynamics of Salvation; a Study in Gregory of Nazianzus. (Patristic Monograph Series; 7). Cambridge, MA: Philadelphia Patristic Foundation.
Wolterstorff, Nicholas. 1991. ‘Divine Simplicity’, in Philosophical Perspectives, 5: Philosophy of Religion, ed. James E. Tomberlin. Atascadero, CA: Ridgeview, 531–52.
Worthen, J. F. 1998. ‘Augustine's De Trinitate and Anselm's Proslogion: “Exercere Lectorem” ’, in Leinhard 1998, 517–29.
Young, Robin Darling. 1997. ‘Theologia in the Early Church’. Communio 24: 681–90.