Brute Rationality

Normativity and Human Action

Brute Rationality

Joshua Gert presents a new account of normative practical reasons and the way in which they contribute to the rationality of action. He argues that, rather than simply "counting in favor of" action, normative reasons play two logically distinct roles--that of requiring action and that of justifying action. Gert's book will appeal to a range of readers interested in practical reasoning in particular, and moral theory more generally.


"It is a great contribution to contemporary philosophical debate and is likely to make an impact."
Philosophy in Review

"Brute Rationality is a very fine book. It is crisply written, laced with wit, and carefully argued.... I recommend Brute Rationality to anyone who is interested in issues of practical rationality and how they bear upon moral theory."

"Brute Rationality is a remarkable book. It is elegant and engaging, and it aims to deliver s traightfoward solutions to problems not addressed by other theories of practical rationality. The theory of normative reasons developed in Brute Rationality is both detailed and novel." - Sergio Tenenbaum, University of Toronto

Alston, W. 1991. Perceiving God, Ithaca, Cornell University Press
Anscombe, G. E. M. 1995. “Practical Inference” in Hursthouse et al. 1995, pp. 1–34
Arthur, J. and Shaw, W.(eds.) 1991. Justice and Economic Distribution, New Jersey, Prentice Hall
Audi, R. 1985. “Rationalization and Rationality” Synthese 65, 159–84
Audi, R. 1997. Moral Knowledge and Ethical Character, New York, Oxford University Press
Baier, K. 1954. “The Point of View of Morality” Australasian Journal of Philosophy 32, 104–35
Baier, K. 1965. The Moral Point of View, New York, Random House
Baier, K. 1978. “Moral Reasons and Reasons to be Moral” in Goldman and Kim 1978, pp. 231–56
Balguy, J. 1978. The Foundation of Moral Goodness (1728), facsimile edition, New York, Garland Press
Binkley, R., Bronaugh, R., and Marras, A.(eds.) 1971. Agent, Action, and Reason, Toronto, Toronto University Press
Blackburn, S. 1995. “The Flight to Reality” in Hursthouse et al. 1995, pp. 35–56
Brandt, R. 1979. A Theory of the Good and the Right, Oxford, Oxford University Press
Brink, D. 1986. “Externalist Moral Realism” Southern Journal of Philosophy 24, 23–42
Broome, J. 1999. “Normative Requirements” Ratio 12, 398–419
Cahn, S. and Haber, J.(eds.) 1995. Twentieth Century Ethical Theory, New Jersey, Prentice Hall
Chang, R.(ed.) 1997 Incommensurability, Incomparability, and Practical Reason, Cambridge, Harvard University Press
Clarke, R. 1994. “Doing What One Wants Less: A Reappraisal of the Law of Desire” Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 75, 1–10
Clarke, S. 1978. Works of Samuel Clarke, vol. 2 (1738), facsimile edition, New York, Garland Press
Cohen, G. A.1996. “Reason, Humanity, and the Moral Law” in Korsgaard, 1996a, pp. 167–88
Cohon, R. 1986. “Are External Reasons Impossible?” Ethics 96, 545–56
Copp, D. 1995. Morality, Normativity, and Society, New York, Oxford University Press
Copp, D. 1997. “Belief, Reason, and Motivation: Michael Smith's The Moral Problem” Ethics 108, 33–54
Cullity, G. and Gaut, B.(eds.) 1997. Ethics and Practical Reason, New York, Clarendon Press
Dancy, J. 2000. Practical Reality, New York, Oxford University Press
Darwall, S. 1983. Impartial Reason, Ithaca, Cornell University Press
Darwall, S. 1990. “Autonomist Internalism and the Justification of Morals” Noûs 24, 257–68
Darwall, S. 1992. “Internalism and Agency” in J. Tomberlin (ed.), Philosophical Perspectives 6, Ethics, Atascadero, Ridgeview, pp. 155–74
Darwall, S. 1994. “From Morality to Virtue and Back” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 54, 695–701
Darwall, S. 1999. “Ethical Intuitionism and the Motivation Problem” presented at Jornadas Internacionales de Etica y Derecho, Universidad Torcuato Di Tella, Buenos Aires, June 23, 1999
Davidson, D. 1963. “Actions, Reasons, and Causes” Journal of Philosophy 60, 685–99
Davidson, D. 1980. “Freedom to Act” in his Essays on Actions and Events, Oxford, Clarendon Press, pp. 63–81
Davies, M.and Humberstone, L. 1980. “Two Notions of Necessity” Philosophical Studies 38, 1–30
Deigh, J. 1996. “Reason and Motivation” in J. Deigh, The Sources of Moral Agency, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, pp. 133–59
Doris, J. 1998. “Persons, Situations, and Virtue Ethics” Noûs 32, 504–30
Dreier, J. 1990. “Internalism and Speaker Relativism” Ethics 101, 6–25
Duggan, T. and Gert, B. 1967. “Voluntary Abilities” American Philosophical Quarterly 4, 127–35
Duggan, T. and Gert, B. 1979. “Free Will as the Ability to Will” Noûs 13, 197–217
Edgley, R. 1965. “Practical Reasoning” Mind 74, 174–91
Foley, R. 1991. “Rationality, Belief and Commitment” Synthese 89, 365–92
Foley, R. 1992, “The Epistemology of Belief and Degrees of Belief” American Philosophical Quarterly 29, 111–24
Foot, P. 1978a. “Morality as a System of Hypothetical Imperatives” in Foot 1978c, pp. 157–73
Foot, P. 1978b. “Reasons for Action and Desires” in Foot 1978c, pp. 148–56
Foot, P. 1978c. Virtues and Vices, Oxford, Basil Blackwell
Gert, B. 1998. Morality: Its Nature and Justification, New York, Oxford University Press
Gert, J. 2002a. “Expressivism and Language Learning” Ethics 112, 292–312
Gert, J. 2002b. “Avoiding the Conditional Fallacy” Philosophical Quarterly 52, 88–95
Gibbard, A. 1990. Wise Choices, Apt Feelings, Cambridge, Harvard University Press
Goldman, A. and Kim, J.(eds.) 1978. Values and Morals, Boston, Reidel Publishing Co
Good, I. J. 1952. “Rational Decisions” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Ser. B. 14, 107–14
Greenspan, P. 1975. “Conditional Oughts and Hypothetical Imperatives” Journal of Philosophy 72, 259–76
Hardin, C. L. 1993. Color for Philosophers, expanded edition, Indianapolis, Hackett Publishing Co
Hare, R. M. 1971. “Wanting: Some Pitfalls” in Binkley et al. 1971, pp. 81–97
Harman, G. 1982. “Review of A Theory of the Good and the Right by Richard Brandt” Philosophical Studies 42, 119–39
Heath, J. 1997. “Foundationalism and Practical Reason” Mind 106, 451–73
Herman, B. 1993. The Practice of Moral Judgment, Cambridge, Harvard University Press
Hobbes, T. 1994. Leviathan (1651), E. Curley (ed.), Indianapolis, Hackett
Hume, D. 1978. A Treatise of Human Nature, L. A. Selby-Bigge and P. H. Nidditch (eds.), Oxford, Clarendon Press
Hursthouse, R., Lawrence, G., and Quinn, W.(eds.) 1995. Virtues and Reasons: Philippa Foot and Moral Theory, New York, Oxford University Press
Isen, A. M.and Levin, H. 1972. “The Effect of Feeling Good on Helping: Cookies and Kindness” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 21, 384–88
Johnson, R. 1999. “Internal Reasons and the Conditional Fallacy” Philosophical Quarterly 49, 53–71
Kagan, S. 1989. The Limits of Morality, New York, Oxford University Press
Kane, R. 1996. The Significance of Free Will, New York, Oxford University Press
Kant, I. 1988. Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of Morals (1785), T. K. Abbott (trans.), Amherst NY, Prometheus Books
Korsgaard, C. 1996a. The Sources of Normativity, Onora O'Neill (ed.), Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
Korsgaard, C. 1996b. “Skepticism about Practical Reason” in her Creating the Kingdom of Ends, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, pp. 311–34
Korsgaard, C. 1997. “The Normativity of Instrumental Reason” in Cullity and Gaut 1997, pp. 215–54
Lawrence, G. 1995. “The Rationality of Morality” in Hursthouse et al. 1995, pp. 89–147
Lewis, D. 1989. “Dispositional Theories of Value” Aristotelian Society, Suppl. 63, 113–37
Mackie, J. L. 1977. Ethics: Inventing Right and Wrong, Harmondsworth, Penguin
McDowell, J. 1995. “Two Sorts of Naturalism” in Hursthouse et al. 1995, pp. 149–79
Mele, A. 1989. “Motivational Internalism: The Powers and Limits of Practical Reasoning” Philosophia 19, 417–36
Mele, A. 1998. “Motivational Strength” Noûs 32, 23–36
Mele, A. 2000. “Goal-Directed Action: Teleological Explanations, Causal Theories, and Deviance” Philosophical Perspectives 14, 279–300
Mele, A. 2003. Motivation and Agency, New York, Oxford University Press
Mill, J. S. 1979. Utilitarianism (1861), George Sher (ed.), Indianapolis, Hackett
Millikan, R. G. 2000. On Clear and Confused Ideas, New York, Cambridge University Press
Morris, C. W. and Ripstein, A.(eds.) 2001. Practical Rationality and Preference, New York, Cambridge University Press
Nagel, T. 1970. The Possibility of Altruism, Princeton, Princeton University Press
Nozick, R. 1993. The Nature of Rationality, Princeton, Princeton University Press
Pattit, D. 1986. Reasons and Persons, Oxford, Oxford University Press
Pattit, D. 1997. “Reasons and Motivation” Aristotelian Society, Suppl. 71, 99–131
Pattit, D. 2001. “Bombs and Coconuts, or Rational Irrationality” in Morris and Ripstein 2001, pp. 81–97
Pettit, P. 1991. “Realism and Response-Dependence” Mind 100, 587–626
Pettit, P.and Smith, M. 1993. “Practical Unreason” Mind 102, 53–79
Philips, M. 1987. “Weighing Moral Reasons” Mind 96, 367–75
Quinn, W. 1995. “Putting Rationality in its Place” in Hursthouse et al. 1995, pp. 181–208
Railton, P. 1986. “Facts and Values” Philosophical Topics 14, 5–31
Rawls, J. 1971. A Theory of Justice, Cambridge, Harvard University Press
Raz, J. 1975. “Permissions and Supererogation” American Philosophical Quarterly 12, 161–68
Raz, J. 1985–6. “Value Incommensurability: Some Preliminaries” Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 86, 117–34
Raz, J. 1999a. Practical Reason and Norms, New York, Oxford University Press
Raz, J. 1999b. Engaging Reason, New York, Oxford University Press
Rescher, N. 1987. “Rationality and Moral Obligation” Synthese 72, 29–43
Rescher, N. 1994. “Replies to Commentators” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 54, 441–57
Ripstein, A. 2001. “Preference” in Morris and Ripstein 2001, pp. 37–55
Rosati, C. 1995. “Persons, Perspectives, and Full Information Accounts of the Good” Ethics 105, 296–325
Ross, D. 1939. The Foundations of Ethics, New York, Oxford University Press
Scanlon, T. 1998. What We Owe to Each Other, Cambridge, Harvard University Press
Scheffler, S. 1995. The Rejection of Consequentialism, Oxford, Clarendon Press
Sen, A. and Williams, B.(eds.) 1982. Utilitarianism and Beyond, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
Sidgwick, H. 1981. The Methods of Ethics (1907), Indianapolis, Hackett
Singer, M. 1996. “Reason, Humanity, and the Moral Law” in Korsgaard 1996, pp. 167–88
Singer, P. 1972. “Famine, Affluence, and Morality” Philosophy and Public Affairs 1, 229–42
Skorupski, J. 1999. “Irrealist Cognitivism” Ratio 12, 436–59
Slote, M. 1984. “Morality and Self-Other Asymmetry” Journal of Philosophy 81, 179–92
Slote, M. 1992. From Morality to Virtue, New York, Oxford University Press
Smart, J. 1991. “Distributive Justice and Utilitarianism” in Arthur and Shaw (eds.) 1991, pp. 106–17
Smith, M. 1994. The Moral Problem, Cambridge, Blackwell
Smith, M. 1995. “Internal Reasons” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 55, 109–31
Smith, M. 1996. “Normative Reasons and Full Rationality: Reply to Swanton” Analysis 56, 160–68
Smith, M. 2002. “Bernard Gert's Complex Hybrid Conception of Rationality” in R. Audi and W. Sinnott-Armstrong (eds.), Rationality, Rules, and Ideals: Critical Essays on Bernard Gert's Moral Theory, Boston, Rowman and Littlefield, pp. 109–23
Sobel, D. 2001. “Subjective Accounts of Reasons for Action” Ethics 111, 461–92
Stampe, D. 1987. “The Authority of Desire” Philosophical Review 96, 335–81
Stocker, M. 1994. “Self-Other Asymmetries and Virtue Theory” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 54, 689–94
Strang, C. 1995. “What if Everyone Did That?” in Cahn and Haber 1995, pp. 378–85
Svavarsdóttir, S. 1999. “Moral Cognitivism and Motivation” Philosophical Review 108, 161–219
Thalberg, I. 1985. “Questions about Motivational Strength” in E. LePore and B. McLaughlin (eds.), Actions and Events, Oxford, Basil Blackwell, pp. 88–103
Tilley, J. 1997. “Motivation and Practical Reasons” Erkenntnis 47, 105–27
Velleman, D. 1996. “The Possibility of Practical Reason” Ethics 106, 694–726
Weirich, P. 2001. “Risk's Place in Decisions Rules” Synthese 126, 427–41
Wiggins, D. 1998. Needs, Values, Truth, 3rd edn., New York, Oxford University Press
Williams, B. 1981. “Internal and External Reasons” his in Moral Luck, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, pp. 101–13
Wittgenstein, L. 1953. Philosophical Investigations, New York, Macmillan