11 - NETWORKS – The assessment of marine reserve networks: guidelines for ecological evaluation  pp. 293-321

NETWORKS – The assessment of marine reserve networks: guidelines for ecological evaluation

By Kirsten Grorud-Colvert et al.

Image View Previous Chapter Next Chapter


As marine ecosystems are plagued by an ever-increasing suite of threats including climate change, pollution, habitat degradation, and fisheries impacts (Roessig et al., 2004; Lotze et al., 2006; Jackson, 2008), there are now no ocean areas that are exempt from anthropogenic impacts (Halpern et al., 2008). In order to preserve marine biodiversity, ecosystem function, and the goods and services provided by resistant and/or resilient systems, marine reserves have been increasingly recommended as part of an ecosystem-based approach to management (Browman and Stergiou, 2004; Levin et al., 2009). Marine reserves are defined as “areas of the ocean completely protected from all extractive and destructive activities” (Lubchenco et al., 2003) and can be experimental controls for evaluating the impact of these activities on marine ecosystems. Growing scientific information has shown consistent increases in species density, biomass, size, and diversity in response to full protection inside reserves of varying sizes and ages located in diverse regions (Claudet et al., 2008; Lester et al., 2009; Molloy et al., 2009). However, most of these data are from individual marine reserves and therefore have inherently limited transferability to networks of marine reserves, which when properly designed can outperform single marine reserves for a variety of ecological, economic, and social management goals (Roberts et al., 2003; Almany et al., 2009; Gaines et al., 2010).

The concept of marine reserve networks grew out of a desire to achieve both conservation and fishery management goals by minimizing the potential negative economic, social, and cultural impacts of a single large reserve while still producing similar or even greater ecological and economic returns (Murray et al., 1999; Gaines et al., 2010). In addition, reserves networks can provide insurance by protecting areas across a region and spreading the risk that these sites may be impacted by localized catastrophes such as hurricanes or oil spills (Allison et al., 2003). The World Conservation Union's Marine Programme defines a network as “a collection of individual marine protected areas (MPAs) or reserves operating co-operatively and synergistically, at various spatial scales and with a range of protection levels that are designed to meet objectives that a single reserve cannot achieve” (IUCN–WCPA, 2008). However, general terms such as “co-operatively” and “synergistically” can have myriad meanings. Without a clear definition of a network, it becomes difficult to identify attainable management goals and design a process for evaluating whether the network achieves those goals. Besides, different management goals may in turn result in the need for different types of networks. The use of MPAs with varying protection levels together with no-take zones in multiple-zoning schemes adds another layer of complexity to network design and evaluation; however, partially protected areas are generally used to manage coastal uses and avoid conflicts (rather than for strict ecological purposes) and are therefore a function of the local social, economic, and cultural context. As we are here interested in the ecological effects of networks, for the purposes of this chapter, we focus on marine reserves because these areas are no-take and therefore offer greater ecological benefits than other types of MPAs that allow some forms of extraction (Lester and Halpern, 2008).

Allison, G. W.Gaines, S. D.Lubchenco, J.Possingham, H. P.2003Ensuring persistence of marine reserves: catastrophes require adopting an insurance factorEcological Applications13S8
Almany, G. R.Connolly, S. R.Heath, D. D.2009Connectivity, biodiversity conservation and the design of marine reserve networks for coral reefsCoral Reefs28339
Ammann, A. J.2004SMURFs: standard monitoring units for the recruitment of temperate reef fishesJournal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology299135
Baskett, M. L.Micheli, F.Levin, S. A2007Designing marine reserves for interacting species: insights from theoryBiological Conservation137163
Beech, T.Dowd, M.Field, C.Hatcher, B.Andrefouet, S2008A stochastic approach to marine reserve design: incorporating data uncertaintyEcological Informatics3321
Berkley, H. A.Kendall, B. E.Mitarai, S.Siegel, D. A.2010Turbulent dispersal promotes species coexistenceEcology Letters13360
Browman, H. I.Stergiou, K. I2004Marine protected areas as a central element of ecosystem-based management: defining their location, size and numberMarine Ecology Progress Series274271
Capitini, C. A.Tissot, B. N.Carroll, M. S.Walsh, W. J.Peck, S.2004Competing perspectives in resource protection: the case of marine protected areas in west Hawai'iSociety and Natural Resources17763
Chapman, D. D.Pikitch, E. K.Babcock, E. A.Shivji, M. S.2005Marine reserve design and evaluation using automated acoustic telemetry: a case-study involving coral reef-associated sharks in the Mesoamerican CaribbeanMarine Technology Society Journal3942
Claudet, J.Osenberg, C. W.Benedetti-Cecchi, L.2008Marine reserves: size and age do matterEcology Letters11481
Claudet, J.Pelletier, D.2004Marine protected areas and artificial reefs: A review of the interactions between management and scientific studiesAquatic Living Resources17129
Costello, C.Rassweiler, A.Siegel, D.2010107
Cowen, R. K.2002Oceanographic influences on larval dispersal and retention and their consequences for population connectivityCoral Reef FishesP. F. SaleYorkAcademic Press149
Cowen, R. K.Lwiza, K. M. M.Sponaugle, S.Paris, C. B.Olson, D. B.2000Connectivity of marine populations: open or closedScience287857
Cowen, R. K.Paris, C. B.Srinivasan, A.2006Scaling of connectivity in marine populationsScience311522
Cudney-Bueno, R.Lavin, M. F.Marinone, S. G.Raimondi, P. T.Shaw, W. W.2009Rapid effects of marine reserves via larval dispersalPLoS One4
Dufour, V.Ricklet, E.Lo-Yat, A1996Colonization of reef fishes at Moorea Island, French Polynesia: temporal and spatial variation of the larval fluxMarine and Freshwater Research47413
Eisma-Osorio, R. L.Amolo, R. C.Maypa, A. P.White, A. T.Christie, P2009Scaling up local government initiatives toward ecosystem-based fisheries management in southeast Cebu Island, PhilippinesCoastal Management37291
Fernandes, L.Day, J.Lewis, A.2005Establishing representative no-take areas in the Great Barrier Reef: large-scale implementation of theory on marine protected areasConservation Biology191733
Field, S. A.O’Connor, D. J.Tyre, A. J.Possingham, H. P.2007Making monitoring meaningfulAustral Ecology32485
Field, S. A.Tyre, A. J.Jonzen, N.Rhodes, J. R.Possingham, H. P.2004Minimizing the cost of environmental management decisions by optimizing thresholdsEcology Letters7669
Fisher, R.Bellwood, D. R.2002The influence of swimming speed on sustained swimming performance of late-stage reef fish larvaeMarine Biology140801
Friedlander, A. M.Brown, E. K.Monaco, M. E.2007Coupling ecology and GIS to evaluate efficacy of marine protected areas in HawaiiEcological Applications17715
Friedlander, A. M.Brown, E.Monaco, M. E.2007Defining reef fish habitat utilization patterns in Hawaii: comparisons between marine protected areas and areas open to fishingMarine Ecology Progress Series351221
Gaines, S. D.White, C.Carr, M. H.Palumbi, S.2010107
Gaspar, C.Bambridge, T.2008Territorialités et aires marines protégées à Moorea (Polynésie française)Journal de la Société des Océanistes126
Gerber, L. R.Botsford, L. W.Hastings, A.2003Population models for marine reserve design: a retrospective and prospective synthesisEcological Applications13S47
Glasby, T. M.1997Analysing data from post-impact studies using asymmetrical analysis of variance: a case study of epibiota on marinasAustralian Journal of Ecology22448
Guichard, F.Levin, S. A.Hastings, A.Siegel, D.2004Toward a dynamic metacommunity approach to marine reserve theoryBioScience541003
Guidetti, P.Claudet, J.2010Comanagement practices enhance fisheries in marine protected areasConservation Biology24312
Halpern, B. S.2003The impact of marine reserves: do reserves work and does reserve size matterEcological Applications13S117
Halpern, B. S.Walbridge, S.Selkoe, K. A.2008A global map of human impact on marine ecosystemsScience319948
Hamilton, S. L.Caselle, J. E.Malone, D.Carr, M. H.2010107
Hastings, A.Botsford, L. W.2003Comparing designs of marine reserves for fisheries and for biodiversityEcological Applications13S65
Heupel, M. R.Semmons, J. M.Hobday, A. J.2006Automated acoustic tracking of aquatic animals: scales, design and deployment of listening station arraysMarine and Freshwater Research571
Jackson, J. B. C.2008Ecological extinction and evolution in the brave new oceanProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America10511 458
Johannes, R. E.1981Working with fishermen to improve coastal tropical fisheries and resource managementBulletin of Marine Science31673
Johannes, R. E.1982Traditional conservation methods and protected marine areas in OceaniaAmbio11258
Jones, G. P.Almany, G. R.Russ, G. R.2009Larval retention and connectivity among populations of corals and reef fishes: history, advances and challengesCoral Reefs28307
Joseph, L. N.Elkin, C.Martin, T. G.Possingham, H. P.2009Modeling abundance using N-mixture models: the importance of considering ecological mechanismsEcological Applications19631
Kaplan, D. M.Botsford, L. W.O’Farrell, M. R.Gaines, S. D.Jorgensen, S.2009Model-based assessment of persistence in proposed marine protected area designsEcological Applications19433
Kark, S.Levin, N.Grantham, H. S.Possingham, H. P.2009Between-country collaboration and consideration of costs increase conservation planning efficiency in the Mediterranean BasinProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America10615 368
Klein, C. J.Chan, A.Kircher, L.2008Striking a balance between biodiversity conservation and socioeconomic viability in the design of marine protected areasConservation Biology22691
Lester, S. E.Halpern, B. S.2008Biological responses in marine no-take reserves versus partially protected areasMarine Ecology Progress Series36749
Lester, S. E.Halpern, B. S.Grorud-Colvert, K.2009Biological effects within no-take marine reserves: a global synthesisMarine Ecology Progress Series38433
Levin, P. S.Kaplan, I.Grober-Dunsmore, R.2009A framework for assessing the biodiversity and fishery aspects of marine reservesJournal of Applied Ecology46735
Lison de Loma, T.Osenberg, C. W.Shima, J. S.2008A framework for assessing impacts of marine protected areas in Moorea (French Polynesia)Pacific Science62431
Lotze, H. K.Lenihan, H. S.Bourque, B. J.2006Depletion, degradation, and recovery potential of estuaries and coastal seasScience3121806
Lowe, C. G.Topping, D. T.Cartamil, D. P.Papastamatiou, Y. P.2003Movement patterns, home range, and habitat utilization of adult kelp bass in a temperate no-take marine reserveMarine Ecology Progress Series256205
Lowry, G. K.White, A. T.Christie, P.2009Scaling up to networks of marine protected areas in the Philippines: biophysical, legal, institutional, and social considerationsCoastal Management37274
Lubchenco, J.Palumbi, S. R.Gaines, S. D.Andelman, S.2003Plugging a hole in the ocean: the emerging science of marine reservesEcological Applications13S3
Mapstone, B.1996Scalable decision criteria for environmental impact assessment: effect size, Type I, and Type II errorsDetecting Ecological Impacts: Concepts and Applications in Coastal HabitatsR. J. SchmittC. W. OsenbergSan Diego, CAAcademic Press67
Meyer, C. G.Holland, K. N.Wetherbee, B. M.Lowe, C. G.2000Movement patterns, habitat utilization, home range size and site fidelity of whitesaddle goatfish, , in a marine reserveEnvironmental Biology of Fishes59235
Mitarai, S.Siegel, D. A.Watson, J. R.Dong, C.McWilliams, J. C.2009Quantifying connectivity in the coastal ocean with application to the Southern California BightJournal of Geophysical Research – Oceans114
Molloy, P. P.McLean, I. B.Cote, I. M.2009Effects of marine reserve age on fish populations: a global meta-analysisJournal of Applied Ecology46743
Monaco, M. E.Weisberg, S. B.Lowery, T. A.1998Summer habitat affinities of estuarine fish in US mid-Atlantic coastal systemsFisheries Management and Ecology5161
Murray, S. N.Ambrose, R. F.Bohnsack, J. A.1999No-take reserve networks: sustaining fishery populations and marine ecosystemsFisheries2411
Nielsen, J.Sibert, J.Hobday, A. J.2009Tagging and Tracking of Marine Animals with Electronic DevicesSpringer
Notarbartolo-DiSciara, G.Agardy, T.Hyrenbach, D.Scovazzi, T.Van Klaveren, P.2008The Pelagos Sanctuary for Mediterranean marine mammalsAquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems18367
NRC2001Marine Protected Areas: Tools for Sustaining Ocean EcosystemsWashington, DCNationalAcademy Press
Osenberg, C. W.Bolker, B. M.White, J. S.St. Mary, C.Shima, J. S.2006Statistical issues and study design in ecological restorations: lessons learned from marine reservesFoundations of Restoration EcologyD. A. FalkM. A. PalmerJ. B. ZedlerWashington, DCIsland Press280
Palumbi, S. R.2004Marine reserves and ocean neighborhoods: the spatial scale of marine populations and their managementAnnual Review of Environment and Resources2931
Paris, C. B.Cherubin, L. M.Cowen, R. K.2007Surfing, spinning, or diving from reef to reef: effects on population connectivityMarine Ecology Progress Series347285
Pelc, R.Gaines, S. D.Warner, R. R.Paris, C. B.2010107
Pickett, S. T. A.1989Space-for-time substitution as an alternative to long-term studiesLong-Term Studies in Ecology: Approaches and AlternativesG. E. LikensNew YorkSpringer110
Pittman, S. J.Christensen, J. D.Caldow, C.Menza, C.Monaco, M. E2007Predictive mapping of fish species richness across shallow-water seascapes in the CaribbeanEcological Modelling2049
Planes, S.Jones, G. P.Thorrold, S. R.2009Larval dispersal connects fish populations in a network of marine protected areasProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America1065693
Pollnac, R. B.Christie, P.Cinner, J. E.2010107
Pomeroy, R.Parks, J.Watson, L.2004
Purkis, S. J.Graham, N. A. J.Reigl, B. M200877
Roberts, C. M.Branch, G.Bustamante, R. H.2003Application of ecological criteria in selecting marine reserves and developing reserve networksEcological Applications13S215
Roessig, J. M.Woodley, C. M.Cech, J. J.Hansen, L. J.2004Effects of global climate change on marine and estuarine fishes and fisheriesReviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries14251
Sandwith, T.Shine, C.Hamilton, L.Sheppard, D.2001
Shackeroff, J. M.Hazen, E. L.Crowder, L. B.2009The oceans as peopled seascapesEcosystem-Based Management for the OceansK. L. McLeodH. LeslieWashington, DCIsland Press33
Shanks, A. L.Grantham, B. A.Carr, M. H.2003Propagule dispersal distance and the size and spacing of marine reservesEcological Applications13S159
Simberloff, D.2003The contribution of population and community biology to conservation scienceAnnual Review of Ecology and Systematics19473
Sponaugle, S.Fortuna, J.Grorud, K.Lee, T.2003Dynamics of larval fish assemblages over a shallow coral reef in the Florida KeysMarine Biology143175
Swearer, S. E.Caselle, J. E.Lea, D. W.Warner, R. R.1999Larval retention and recruitment in an island population of a coral-reef fishNature402799
Thorrold, S. R.Jones, G. P.Planes, S.Hare, J. A.2006Transgenerational marking of embryonic otoliths in marine fishes using barium stable isotopesCanadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences631193
Thorrold, S. R.Latkoczy, C.Swart, P. K.Jones, C. M.2001Natal homing in a marine fish metapopulationScience291297
Thorrold, S. R.Zacherl, D. C.Levin, L. A.2007Population connectivity and larval dispersal using geochemical signatures in calcified structuresOceanography2032
Tissot, B. N.2005Integral marine ecology: community-based fishery management in HawaiiWorld Futures6179
Tissot, B. N.Walsh, W. J.Hixon, M. A.2009Hawaiian islands marine ecosystem case study: ecosystem and community-based management in West HawaiiCoastal Management37255
Tissot, B.Walsh, W.Hallacher, L.2004Evaluating effectiveness of a marine protected area network in west Hawai'i to increase productivity of an aquarium fisheryPacific Science58175
Underwood, A. J.1991Beyond BACI: experimental designs for detecting human environmental impacts on temporal variations in natural populationsAustralian Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research42569
Watson, J. R.Mitarai, S.Siegel, D. A.2010Realized and potential larval connectivity in the Southern California BightMarine Ecology Progress Series40131
Wedding, L.Friedlander, A.McGranaghan, M.Yost, R.Monaco, M.2008Using bathymetric LIDAR data to measure benthic habitat complexity associated with coral reef fishesRemote Sensing of the Environment1124159
White, C.Kendall, B. E.Gaines, S.Siegel, D. A.Costello, C.2008Marine reserve effects on fishery profitEcology Letters11370
Willis, T. J.Millar, R. B.Babcock, R. C.Tolimieri, N.2003Burdens of evidence and the benefits of marine reserves: putting Descartes before des horseEnvironmental Conservation3097
Wood, L. J.Fish, L.Laughren, J.Pauly, D.2008Assessing progress towards global marine protection targets: shortfalls in information and actionOryx42340