10 - Reflections on the Combined Bomber Offensive  pp. 231-264

Reflections on the Combined Bomber Offensive

By Williamson Murray

Image View Previous Chapter Next Chapter



Of all the major campaigns of World War II, the Combined Bomber Offensive (CBO), the two-pronged attack by the Royal Air Force (RAF) and the U.S. Army Air Forces, still remains the most controversial. On one side there are the arguments typified by the economist and member of the U.S. United States Strategic Bombing Survey (USSBS), John Kenneth Galbraith, who argued that for all the effort and for all its hideous impact on “innocent” civilians, the CBO simply did not achieve anything of commensurate value. According to Galbraith, the CBO was “perhaps the greatest miscalculation of the war”:

German war production had, indeed, expanded under the bombing. The greatly heralded efforts, those on the ball-bearing and aircraft plants for example emerged as costly failures. Other operations, those against oil and the railroads did have military effect. But strategic bombing had not won the war. At most, it had eased somewhat the task of the ground troops who did. The aircraft, manpower, and bombs used in the campaign had cost the American economy far more in output than they had cost Germany.

Galbraith's deprecating comment, that at most the CBO had saved the lives of a few infantrymen, suggests a pervasive view that contrasts such small savings with the wreckage of some of the world's most cultured and beautiful cities.

Albert SpeerInside the Third ReichNew York1970285
Alfred C. MierzejewskiThe Collapse of the German War Economy, 1944–1945, Allied Airpower and the German National RailwayChapel Hill1988
Allan R. MillettWilliamson MurrayMilitary Effectiveness21988
Andrew KrepinevichThe Army and VietnamBaltimore1988
Anthony VerrierThe Bomber OffensiveLondon1968327
Bernard M. BoylanThe Development of the American Long-Range FighterUniversity of Missouri Dissertation195568
David IrvingThe Mare's NestBoston1968109
David IrvingThe Rise and Fall of the Luftwaffe, The Life of Field Marshal Erhard MilchBoston1973202
Friedhelm GöluckeSchweinfurt und die strategische Luftkriegführung, 1943Paderborn1980
Ian KershawVolksmeinung und Propaganda im Dritten ReichStuttgart1980176
John Kenneth GalbraithA Life in Our Times, MemoirsBoston1981206
Martin MiddlebrookThe Berlin Raids, R.A.F. Bomber Command, Winter 1943–1944London1988
Martin MiddlebrookThe Nuremberg Raid, 30–31 March 1944New York1974
R. V. JonesThe Wizard WarNew York1978
Reflections on the Combined Bomber Offensive,Militärgeschichtliche Mitteilungen511992
Richard OveryThe Air War, 1939–1945London1980123
Robert E. FutrellIdeas, Concepts, Doctrine. A History of Basic Thinking in the United States Air Force, 1907–1964Montgomery1971139
Sir Charles WebsterNoble FranklandThe Strategic Air Offensive Against GermanyLondon1961216
Solly ZuckermanFrom Apes to WarlordsLondon1978216
Timothy TraversThe Killing GroundLondon1988
Webster FranklandThe Strategic Air Offensive Against Germany374
Wesley E. CravenJames E. CateThe Army Air Forces in World War II11948149
Williamson MurrayGerman Response to Victory in Poland: A Case Study in ProfessionalismArmed Forces and SocietyWinter1981
Williamson MurrayLuftwaffeBaltimore, MD198560
Williamson MurrayStrategy for Defeat, The Luftwaffe 1933–1945Montgomery, AL1983
Williamson MurrayThe Change in the European Balance of Power, 1938–1939: The Path to RuinPrinceton1984326
Williamson MurrayThe Luftwaffe, 1933–1945, Strategy for DefeatWashington, DC, Brassey's1996254