Secretary or General?
The UN Secretary-General in World Politics
Edited by Simon Chesterman
Foreword by Kofi A. Annan
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Print Publication Year: 2007
Online Publication Date:January 2010
Chapter DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511618680.007
The peacemaking function of the Secretary-General is conducted both in fulfilment of mandates entrusted to him by the Security Council – the “unstable and uneasy” relationship analysed by James Cockayne and David M. Malone in chapter 4 of this volume – and action outside such mandates, in the somewhat nebulous territory of “good offices”. This chapter explores an important means by which the Secretary-General may enhance his or her ability to influence the resolution of conflicts: the creation of informal and issue-specific small coalitions of states known as “groups of friends”.
The interaction with groups of friends highlights, as do other chapters in this volume, the tension between the fragile independence of the Secretary-General and the interests of the UN member states. Success has come when the Secretary-General has been able to engage the support, political leverage, and resources of friends behind a sustained peace effort. But it is not guaranteed. As an auxiliary device, a group of friends will not be able to overcome underlying conditions adverse to the resolution of a conflict; and in situations in which the interests of the states involved prioritize other issues – such as their own influence in a conflict environment or the bottom line of one or other of the conflict parties – over a settlement, their involvement may complicate rather than facilitate the Secretary-General's diplomacy.
Good offices, means, and resources
The concept of good offices is not itself mentioned in the UN Charter. It is, perhaps, implied within Article 33(1), which lists “other peaceful means of their own choice” among measures available to states to achieve the peaceful settlement of disputes, especially if read in conjunction with Article 99, which gives the Secretary-General a measure of discretion in areas of peace and security.
APPENDIX: selected documents on the Secretary-General