FOUR - American Imprints and the Middle East's New Human Rights Landscape  pp. 150-199

American Imprints and the Middle East's New Human Rights Landscape

By Shadi Mokhtari

Image View Previous Chapter Next Chapter



In the post–September 11 era, the Middle East stood at the center of American experiments with both the violation and promotion of international human rights norms. This chapter traces how the Middle East's human rights landscape was transformed through the chain of events set in motion by these American experiments. The chapter begins by considering the contradictory effects of American post–September 11th human rights transgressions – the new prism through which the international legal system came to be filtered in the Middle East – on human rights consciousness in the region. The chapter then turns its attention to the American reform agenda, its co-opting by Middle Eastern governments, and its tentative openings for moving the Middle Eastern human rights project forward. The final section highlights transformations emerging from the confluence of both American abuses and promotion initiatives within the realm of religious/secular dynamics in the Middle East's human rights field. By assembling a string of empirical snapshots reflecting Middle Eastern voices and experiences during the era, the chapter draws a picture of the period as characterized by considerable engagement, flux, and transformation – at some junctures regressive or illusory, at others tangible and far-reaching – amid the backdrop of its successive human rights failings.

HUMAN RIGHTS THROUGH THE PRISM OF AMERICAN VIOLATIONS

An immense sense of disillusionment and false promise has pervaded the Middle Eastern encounter with human rights in the post–September 11th era.

Brutality a Symptom of Ingrained Racism, Doha Gulf Times, May 1, 2004
Contempt for Law, Arab News, Feb. 17, 2006
In Retrospect, Arab News, Apr. 24, 2006
Outsourcing Torture, Arab News, May 21, 2005
Anthony Chase, The Tail and the Dog: Constructing Islam and Human Rights in Political Context, in Human Rights in the Arab World: Independent Voices (Anthony Chase and Amr Hamzawi eds., 2007)
Babak Dehghanpisheh, Baghdad Mission, Newsweek, August 11, 2007
Carrie Wickham, The Problem with Coercive Democratization: The Islamist Response to the U.S. Democracy Reform Initiative, 1:1 Muslim World J. Hum. Rts. (2004)
Dan Murphy, Abu Ghraib Holds Mirror to Arabs, christian science monitor, Jun. 4, 2004
Haifa Zangana, The Three Cyclops of Empire-Building: Targeting the Fabric of Iraqi Society, in Empire's Law, The American Imperial Project and the War to Remake the World 254–255 (Amy Bartholomew ed., 2006)
Janine A. Clark, The Conditions of Islamist Moderation: Unpacking Cross-Ideological Cooperation, 38 Int. J. Middle East Stud. 539, at 553–554 (2006)
Jutta Brunnee and Stephan Toope, International Law and Constructivism: Elements of an Interactional Theory of International Law, 39 Colum. J. Transnat'l L. 19 (2000)
Kawkab al-Thaibani, HOOD, Families Demand Closure of Guantanamo, Yemen Observer, Jan. 19, 2007
Martha Finnmore and Kathryn Sikkink, International Norm Dynamics and Political Change, 52 Int'l Org. 887 (1998)
Mohammad Ben Hussein, Journalists Say Access to Information Law Hinders Press Freedoms, Jordan Times, Jun. 24, 2007
Rana Husyni, King Orders Jafr Prison Closed, Jordan Times, Dec. 18, 2006
Thomas Risse and Katheryn Sikkink, The Socialization of International Human Rights Norms into Domestic Practices: Introduction, in The Power of Human Rights 7 (Thomas Risse, Stephen Ropp, and Kathryn Sikkink eds., 1999)