3 - Die Vernunft des List. National economy and the critique of cosmopolitan economy  pp. 32-65

<i>Die Vernunft des List</i>. National economy and the critique of cosmopolitan economy

By Keith Tribe

Image View Previous Chapter Next Chapter



His object is to transplant economic theory (Staatswirtschaftslehre) from the lecture hall to the office, and in this he succeeds admirably. Such a book, making the most important parts of economics common property and illuminating austere thought processes with striking illustrations in a readable, conversational style, cannot fail also in Germany to find a larger public.

So wrote Friedrich List to the publisher J.G. Cotta in 1822, offering to translate Louis Say's Considerations sur l'industrie et la législation, a book which presented a series of readable summaries of recent economic treatises. Nothing came of this particular proposal to translate Say; but the project of rendering economic principles accessible to a wider popular audience was one which List later made his own. Unlike Louis Say, however, he eschewed straightforward summary of the principles advanced by contemporary economic writers. Instead, he developed a systematic critique of economic orthodoxies, a critique that turned on his contention that the intellectual legacy of Adam Smith was marked by an artificial divorce of politics from economics. As a consequence, he suggested, political distinctions and national interests failed to find a place in a doctrinal system that assumed a world ruled by general, universally valid economic laws. The ‘School’, as he dubbed the heirs of Adam Smith, therefore practised a Cosmopolitical Economy, rather than a true Political Economy which recognised the exigencies of national interests and political forces.