Contesting Global Governance
Multilateral Economic Institutions and Global Social Movements
By Robert O'Brien
By Anne Marie Goetz
By Jan Aart Scholte
By Marc Williams
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Print Publication Year: 2000
Online Publication Date:September 2009
Chapter DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511491603.004
This chapter examines the relationship between the World Trade Organization (WTO) and labour. The analysis proceeds in the following manner. Firstly, an overview is provided of the WTO and its significance. Secondly, the global labour movement is profiled and some preliminary points are made about its status in the social movement and NGO community. Thirdly, labour's engagement with international economic institutions other than the WTO is surveyed. Fourthly, labour's particular concern with the WTO is explained. Fifthly, labour participation in the first ministerial meeting of the WTO is examined for what it reveals about both the WTO and labour. Sixthly, the general relationship between NGOs and the WTO is surveyed. Finally, the implications of the WTO–labour engagement for the International Labour Organisation is considered.
The primary argument of the chapter is that labour's inability to advance its concerns in the WTO framework risks losing a potentially significant constituency. Organised labour is more supportive of the WTO's trade liberalisation project than other elements of the social movement community. Disagreement with various NGOs over the social clause issue highlights organised labour's desire to work within dominant institutions. However, the meagre results of the WTO Singapore Ministerial meeting, continued resistance at the WTO and increased opposition to reform of the ILO put continued cooperation in doubt. For a multilateral institution seeking to sink roots in national societies such a development should be a cause for concern.